=gggggggggggggggggggggggggg= = = = `ma"ob`masp3 #bjbc-ja-ja = = 333333333333333333333333 = = ~1$3i{7"x~)ju"1 = = #aa-acgajbh-jjjicj-ja = = 333333333333333333333333 = = #bjbb c* e1em7;o j5w = = ~g,? eo2 *`m = = = =77777777777777777777777777= *`m;rao5."1 `o5o1jv3 `ma"ob`masp3 ----------------------------#j-a =gggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg= .n;&eg `ma"ob`masp3.7 `mrj `ma"ob`masp3`v ;n`|j3 *`m+7:a `/>an ,i"< ,8#bjbb c* e1em7;o j5w ~g,? eo2 *`m0'n `v3j3 *`m ~u`u,s"! .a,}j<: .n;&jbcoi4 _7 lsb `o$3"1 #bjbb c* #fp1-- #bjbc c* #ap1 #bjbc c* #ap1 #aio1 *`m;rao5."1 `o5o1jv3 8',},q:ir,0 *`m `o`v3"1 ,},q:.irja`+ *`ml3jaj:b":ai3 `u":irja`+ l3jaj:b":ai3 ;m7c5irja`+ l3jaj:b":ai3 8'.m,0c"<.o,oa.}~u *`m ;rao5."1 `o5o1jv3 #j-a .n;&eg #a `=i= *`mp3"1 $7<"{5" `o5hrm" ~a.qju" ~aj*<" ,=l7j)" ,=},ma" oiu`o1" o.oz" .7j<*" .},!<" .}*.m" .u`};<3" ;y%3.o =777777777777777777777777777777= ----------------------------#j-b `maeg +>a"1 #bjbb c* e1em7;o j5w ~g,? eo2 *`m o lsbz j3`mas q`=.oc{7w `vsb ,mjr7 c{7":a o1~3`v cu4z l7`v3`v3`/"! $k`u o/cz )s ;m"(q ,8j5w ~g,?0'! mrjr ,qeg hna,{h{"u~mhs ,)jr7 i5jv"! ;m;&j`u" o"! `o~3{"u .?ir.? l"/"! ,r7,}j<: q`=.oc{7 d}$+7 ~n3;oef{"u $`=j5{"u,,s .<*s ojr ~n3;oef{w ;mr>a,} eg.n"! ~uv3j`o mrj3 ~7<3! e"*jcz in ex.?o o/i4 o"! mrjr #bjba c* `ma"ob`masp3 ,qeg e1em7;o"u~mhs #g;<"/w "a! `o~3{"u j3 `m;ma .o;o5! ,m"obj<: .?+7j<:/`u" .asbw j+%1,}! ;yirj3{"u cu4o`o mrjr,s .asb+7 ~n3;oef{"! `r~1" #j-b `maeg +>a #c jv1+7j<:/i4 o"! h=jr euim #ec1bad`rw .?ir.? $,t! ,r7,}j<:/i4 j3d* ,r7,}iy3 .?ir.? $,tz ;m"( d3i3w .}jva,}! mrjr #b e}w .asb.a #e ----------------------------#j-d 0,ab/ract3 #bjbb ,rese>* & ,analysis on ,kor1n ,corpus ( ,adv}s>ial ,natural ,language ,9f};e ,? project aims to build natural language "u/&+ "<,,nlu"> b5*-m>k = ! evalua;n ( ,kor1n >tificial 9tellig;e "<,,ai"> ) a focus on xs abil;y to 9f} ! tru? or fals;y ( presuppos$ 3t5ts 9 s5t;es4 ,? l+ui/ic 9f};e is /r;gly correlat$ ) ! ,kor1n ,,ai's g5}al capac;y to p}=m _m d{n/r1m tasks4 ,us+ ! cor-pus ( newspap} texts1 we extract$ 4c|rses & s5t;es 3ta9+ "s presuppos$ 3t5ts & g5}at$ adv}s>ial examples t comple;t ! fragil;y or vuln}abil;y ( curr5t ,,nlu b5*m>ks4 ,m specifically1 we collect$ #fcj1jjj 4c|rses f ! newspap} corpus ( #bjba ,na;nal ,9/itute ( ,kor1n ,language1 up to sev5 r.ds ( data extrac;n proc$ures4 ,we !n employ$ six di6}5t /rategies ( g5}at+ adv}s>ial hypo!sis f newspap} 4c|rses bas$ on ! previ|s rese>* on ,,nlu b5*m>ks4 ,9 addi;n1 we develop$ cr{ds|rc+ plat=ms to help g5}at+ adv}s>ial hypo!sis ) manual annota;n guidel9es4 ,) ? approa*1 we cr1t$ #ec1bad ad-v}s>ial hypo!sis4 ----------------------------#j-e ,= all ! g5}at$ hypo!sis1 two cr{d-"w}s manually 9spect$ :e!r annotat$ data is a3urately cr1t$ )|t fallacy ( ! 9f}5tial judg;t ( annotators4 ,z a result1 annotat$ data is n pass$ 9to ! next /ep ( proc$ures )|t ! agree;t ( ?ree cr{d-"w}s t ! cr1t$ data meets ! annota;n guidel9es4 ,! total numb} ( annotat$ adv}s>ial hypo!sis ) ! agree;t ( cr{d "w}s is #ch1jah4 a#j-d 0,ab/ract4 #g ,9 ! proc$ure ( exam9+ ! usabil;y ( adv}s>ial hypo!sis1 we p}=m$ language model ,8fool+,0 t te/s :e!r ! model is robu/4 ,we te/$ two ,kor1n language models call$ ,,klue- ,ro,,b}t,'a-base & ,,kr-,,b}t4 ,crucially1 adv}s>ial hypo!sis t fails to pass ! fool+ te/ "ial hypo!sis"> >e 4c>d$4 ,! f9al v}.n ( adv}s>ial hypo!sis data 3si/s ( #ba1cjj examples4 ,9 ! la/ proc$ure ( |r project1 we us$ five di6}5t language models = assess+ ! reliabil;y & usabil;y ( ! #bj1jeb examples4 ,we f.d t ad- v}s>ial hypo!sis data is ,8prop},0 to /&>d crit}ia ( ,,nlu b5*m>ks s9ce x m1n+;lly boo/s ! p}=m.e ( te/$ language models4 "9 ,key ~ws3 language model1 ,9f};e1 ,,nlu"<,natural ,language ,"u/&+">1 fool+1 adv}s>ial hypo!sis1 5tail;t1 3tradic;n1 neutral1 corpus4 ----------------------------#j-f b#j-e 0,ab/ract4 #i ----------------------------#j-g ;<"/ ,'.s5:a. .m"1 p3~( dno.o ~)ju .s5. dno.o ~)ju ,g{"u .?{54,' .n#a.7 ,s"( #a4 lsb `r+ """""""""""" #b#ai #b4 lsbw ~s5mrv .qjr7 `v.} """"""""""""""""""""""""" #f#bh #c4 `v3"* *`m i=j>7 """ #aj#cd .n#b.7 ,)jr7 i5jvw ;m;& #a4 ,)jr7 i5jv ;m;& irl7 """""""""""""""""""""""" #ai#di #b4 ,)jr7 i5jv ;m;& `o.g """""""""""""""""""""""" #bj#ec #c4 ,)jr7 i5jv ;m;& `v.} eo2 `|`v """""""""""""""""""" #ba#ee .n#c.7 .?ir.? $,t eg.7w ,r7,} #a4 .?ir.? $,t eg.7 ,r7,}! mrj3 .)">a """""""""""""" #be#fe #b4 .?ir.? $,t eg.7 ,r7,} `v.} #j-g ;<"/ #aa """""""""""""""""""""""" #ca#ge #c4 .asb. $3 `s5,m """" #cd#ha ----------------------------#j-h .n#d.7 )s euin1 ,xo`o 8'0fool+,0 ,o1js5 #a4 )s euin1 ,xo`o ,o1js5 ,t`/ """""""""""""""""""""""" #cg#he #b4 )s euin1 ,xo`o ,o1js5 `|`v """""""""""""""""""""""" #ch#hh .n#e.7 `s5.{7 #a4 `s5.{7 .t;a """""""""""""" #fb#abi #b4 .n) """""""""""""" #fc#acb ;<5`uegj) """""""""" #fd#ace 82~m"x;0 #bjbb c* e1em7;o j5w ~g,? eo2 *`m .o;o5 #fg#ada ----------------------------#j-i d+ ;<"/ ,'.s5:a. .m"1 d+ ;<"/w dno.o ~)jucz p3~(dno.o ~)juo54,' "8d+#a01 j5w_/eu,g_/.m7"ob "<~n1w .}w """""""""""""""""" #g "8d+#b01 .?ir.? j5w ~g,? e1em7;o `m;ma `v.} """"""""" #aj "8d+#c01 }eo`p3 .<*s;m"( ~n3;oef{w l"/ """""""""""""" #aa "8d+#d01 inohs ,nh{w `r+ #ae "8d+#e01 .?ir.? l"/w ~o`+ `|`v """"""""""""""""""""""""""" #af "8d+#f01 .?ir.? l"/"! ja,{bj3 `}mv `{"s0.o <30z `}m 0,,b}t4w ,}c{7 ~o`+ """"""""""""""""" #af "8d+#g01 .?ir.? $,t eg.7 ,r7,} / """""""""""""""""""""""""" #cd "8d+#h01 ,xo`o ,o1js5n jv1+7iy3 )seuin1`v d"4z ;= #i`rw `v.n"u o"ms.: o/{e: o `v.ni!z f{`n 8'#a,0 i3o1eg.7 `v.n" 8'#b,0 %l,}`v sjmr ~*+7 `v.n" 8'#c,0 ;m"( `v.n i{7{"u ~g"%iy1 ,m o/i4 ocz ;y,q .<*s;s"o euin1q 0,,b}t1 ,,gpt-#cw .m+ ,}c{7 d}$ .od+"u `oc{7jr v/.oe3" ;y`z )s euin1i!w ~1.) ,xiu$ ,~1"<.o5n ,i"< 0,sup},,glue"<,a ,/icki} ,b5*m>k = ,g5}al-,purpose ,language ,"u/&+ ,sy/ems1 ,wang et ;al41 #bjbj">4$ .n<3iy`oiu j<:/i4 ac 0,,glue4v 0,sup},,glue4w `}m" euim j3`mas )s euin1w ,}c{7! #a .n#a.7 #a4 #ai d}$j`oncz .?.tj.o eu'j3 e*o o/i4 h{ajo" .<*s;s"o `vsb8'0task,0 .m7 jck et ;al4" #bjba,0 j3`/$ o/i4 o"sj3 l7jv7 ,xn,s ~1.)j`u o/cz j3`mas q`=.oc{7 )s euin1w .<*s ;m"( c{7":a! d}$j`u `{ ,}c{7! cu4o1 ,m o/iu"x ja,{b,ofo`o mrj3 j3`mas j5w ~g,? inohs ,nh{$ do1+je:" o"! mrjr ,8.?ir.?0' ~7,oa! l+7j3 j5w ~g,? e1em7;o"! `m;maj1 do1+,}o f{`n irimiy`u o/i4 ------------------------------#c o,ir ,8.?ir.?0' ~7,oao"< j5z )s euin1o ,mrb`n `|`v"! ;m"(jr cr.o eu'jiu"x wiu.?{"u ;m"( `v3`/"! ,t`/j3 ~7,oa! ,i{'j3i4 .{a inohs ,nh{"! `m;majcz in o/s,s q$3`v )s euin1o i"{`n ;m"(j1 ,m o/cz ~7,oa{"u inohs ,nh{"! `m,}j5{"u `m7`{a.?{"ucz )s euin1w ;m"( c{7":a! q$3`v %lj`sc cu4z ,m.g{"u jg"*,ofo`u. inohs"! `m;majcz ~7,oa! ,8.?ir.?0' ~7,oao"< jcz _soi4 .?ir.? j5w ~7,oa! .?+7j<: `m;maiy3 inohs ,nh{w do1+,}! .}"oje* i<{5`v $8i4 7 0,sup},,glue4w #i$.o d}$ `v.nn,s #d`r `v.n8'0,,,mnli1 qnli1 rte1 wnli,0$ .<*s;m"( ~n3;oef{o5 7 cu4z .<*s;m"( ,}c{7z `m;n.?q j7jm ~1.) ~7j>7! `m;n.?{"u .n,oj5 7 j*ir j3`maqw )s l+7 >7l7! ,m.obj3 e1em7;o"! q`=.oc{7 l3sbn jv1+7$c{7j3 io.oht.a,} eg.n"! ~uv3j`o mrj3 ~7<3! e"*jcz in ex.?o o/i4 h{ajo q`=.oc{7w `{b,xj3 ~1.){"u qj<: q$3`v q`=.oc{7w `v.n ,mjr7 c{7":a ; j1 eg.n"u ~m$aiy`u o/i4 `{i=<3 `r~1iy3 o1~m ~n3;oef{i!! l1d:~u.e*" 0,,rte4cz `udm5.o1w ,m.asb e1em7;oo.oe3" `%eu$ .a< `o`/ja,{bn .?jbj.o <30`u" .).n-$,tn irj3 d}.}o ;n`/.?o.o eu'j3icz j3`/$ o/i4 0,,snli4cz inohs `%eu"! #ajj~r #d .n#a.7 #a4 #bc ol7{"u jva.7j`u" #b1ejj e}w f{"7j3 .7"{n,s .).n"! ;m;&j<: .<*s;m"(w iuenq .)o 8'0doma9-transf},0"! $7jvj<:/i4 0,,scitail4z .m,?.$ qmr.?q $,t! ,r7,}jcz _so ial,0 .sb`z~sb! ;mrj`u o/icz .s5n,s ~( `vsb`v ;m`mjcz ~7j>7o o1;oj3i4 ------------------------------#e ov $8z .<*s;m"( ~n3;oef{w .m+ `r~1 cr+7 h{ajo" 0,,anli4"! .m7,o5{"u j3 j5w ~g,?! .<*sojr ~n3;oef{w `*`u,}8'0robu/;s,0 $7jvw .m+ ;ma{"u ~1.),ofocz _so ~( lsbw ex.?o"<`u j1 ,m o/i4 #a4c4 lsb `|`vw jv1+7`v ww .?ir.? l"/ `o~3{"u `m;maiy3 j5w ~g,? e1em7;ocz m,) j3`mas q`=.oc{7 euin1w ,}c{7 j>7l7n `o:j1 ,m o/i4 <4n,siu .o.?j3 ~7l7n f{`n `o:j1 ,m o/i4 ,iuj3 .?ir.? l"/ `o~3w inohscz ~o`+.? .7`o$3 ,8~n3;oef{0'"u,s a#e .n#a.7 #a4 #be `oc{7j1 ,m o/i4 )s euin1w ~1.) ,xiu$ ,~1"<.oe*,s" ~n3;oef{w `r~1 ,xiu$ o"! ,i"<.b.o eu'j`u o/{5o .o.?iy`oiu j<:/i8'0,nie et ;al4" #bjbj,04 `|`v.?{"u q`=.oc{7 euin1w >a.s5! `=">ajcz .?ir.? l"/i!! h=jr euin1i!o ~n3;oef{ inohs ,nh{w h=`/.? d*j>7! ~m.?.tj`n ja,{bj`sc jv1+7jcz _s! ~7.oj`u" o"! h=jr inohs ,nh{ .;n$ d}$"! mrj3 inohs ,nh{"u,s is u"r %.oiy1 ,m o/i4 j3d* j3`mas"! irl7{"u j3 .?ir.? l"/ `o~3w j5w ~g,? e1em7;o"! h=jr s9! ,m o/cz j+`v"! .u5 is `m;n.?{"u c(wje* i<{5`v $8i4 m,) .?ir.? l"/ ja,{b! h=j3 .<*s;s"o euin1w .}jvaiu"! j>7l7j1 ,m o/i4 `o.(w *`m `|`vq 0,~w,,cnn1 ,~w,,l/m1 ,,b}t4v $8z :"s .="%w .<*s;s"o euin1n,siu euim .?ir.? l"/"! ja,{b inohs"u l+7j3 jmn .}jva,}o cu4<.:/{5o ~u`uiy3 ~ o/i8'0,j9 et ;al41 #bjbj,04 ------------------------------#f ,iuj3 j3`mas .?ir.? l"/ j5w ~g,?n irj3 )s euin1i!w ,}c{7 d}$$ $c{7jr.qi4 .o`{5,$.ocz .?ir.? 0,,nli4"! j3`masn .?+7j3 *`m$ `sw ~&$c{7jr/{e:" `o5eqju y8'#bjbj,0w *`mcz j3`mas"! duj5j3 i`mas"u o"ms.q .?ir.? e1em7;o,80,,paws-;,x0'"! jv1+7j3 _sos/i4 ac jri7 *`mcz ,8i,o,,{`o0'8'0p>aphras+,0 h5.on ;u.s5! im`u o/! ,~g o"! 0,,nli4 *`m"u ~u`oncz s":m5o o/{e:" jri7 e1em7;o ,iuj3 ir{7iycz y`mas ."+w ~):a! h=jr `m;maiys/icz j3`/$ o/i4 ,i"<,s ~( lsb! h=jr j3`mas"u `m;maiy3 ;y;uw .?ir.? j5w ~g,? e1em7;o"! jva~uj`n iy3i4 o e1em7;ocz j3`mas .?ir.? j5w ~g,? e1em7;ow d+.g{"u,sw .omr"! $.o`n iye:" j3`masw .?ir.? e1em7;o `m;man o/s ,)iu.?q :aj1! ,mjr7j5{"u,,s jm,x *`mi!! ;x~1j`n iy1 _soi4 #f .n#a.7 #a4 #bg #b4 lsbw ~s5mrv .qjr7 `v.} #b4a4 lsbw ~s5mr o1~3.?{"u j5w ~g,? 8'0,recogniz+ ,textual ,5tailm5t_/,,rte,0o"<3 .ms.q j3 ,l7w eg.78',)jr7 i5jvv $,t eg.7,0n irj<: im eg.7 $3w `v3`/"! ;m"(jcz `v.n8'0,fyodorov et ;al4 #bjjj2 ,3doravdi et ;al4 #bjjc2 ,bos & ,m>k}t #bjje2 ,dagan et ;al4 #bjje2 ,mac,c>tney & ,mann+ #bjji,0"! e1j3i4 ------------------------------#g o~) `vsbn,scz .ms.q ,)jr7 i5jvv $,t eg.7w ,l7n irj<: im eg.7 $3w `v3`/$ j5w8'05tail;t,0" .m7"ob8'0neutral,0" eu,g 8'03tradic;n,0w ,n $.o "<~n1 8'0label,0 .m7 s,i) `}mn jri7jcz.o"! ;m"(j<: .?jbj3 "<~n1! ~m;7,oa8'0,top-d{n,0 ,r7,} `=.}z f{`n 8'#a,0 ,)jr7 i5jv ;m;& i3`/" 8'#b,0 .?ir.? l"/ ,r7,} i3`/" 8'#c,0 .asb.$3 `s5,m i3`/" 8'#d,0 euin1 ,xo`o8'0fool+,0 i3`/w cn i3`/"u `m,}iy3i4 o `v.}! iu,oajvje* "8d+#b01v $8i4 -----------------------------#aj "8d+#b01 .?ir.? j5w ~g,? e1em7;o `m;ma `v.} =gggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg= 8'#a,0 ,)jr7 i5jv ;m;&"1 ,qeg e1em7;o #bjban,s ,)jr7 eg.7 5 irl7 eg.7 ;m;& 8'#b,0 .?ir.? $,t ,r7,}"1 irl7 eg.7! ~h7{"u j3 .?ir.? l"/ ,r7,} eo2 "<~n1 ~m;7 }eo`p3n,s .<*s;m"( ~n3;oef{cz q`=.oc{7o `m;n.?q `vsb o1~3w ,mjr7 c{7":a`v l7`v3`v3`/$ cu4z ;ml7.?q ,m.gw c("o.? `v3`/"! ojrj`u o/cz.o d}$j`o mrj<: `r~1iys/i4 o"sj3 .<*s;m"( `v.ncz inohsw `%eujv" .7"{w i<>7jv" .m,? `=.}w .}`+jv"! .m+ ;ma{"u j<: ~1.)j<:/czin o"! .}"oje* "8d+#c01`v $8i4 -----------------------------#aa "8d+#c01 }eo`p3 .<*s;m"( ~n3;oef{w l"/ =gggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg= #a ~n3;oef{"1 hna,{h{ j5w q,oa 8'0,,rte-#a,0 inohs `%eu"1 #a1ccg `) 8'0dev "6 te/,0 .).n eg.7 .7"{"1 .m,? e1em7;o 8'.o1w {7ib,0 prb ."+8'c%,{ `ol,0 $,t eg.7 .m,? `=.}"1 .).n eg.7n irj<: ;<5`v `s.o' $,t 8'0,true_/,false hypo!sis,0! ,r7,}j5 #b ~n3;oef{"1 ,{hr3dui{ .<*s;m"( 8'0,,snli,0 inohs `%eu"1 #egj1aeb `) 8'0tra9 "6 dev "6 te/,0 .).n eg.7 .7"{"1 oeo.o frb,* 8'0,flickr #cjk,0 $,t eg.7 .m,? `=.}"1 .m,? .asb.cz #c`rw .).nv j5w 8'05tail;t,0" eu,g 8'03tradic;n,0" .m7"ob 8'0neutral,0 $,t! ,r7,}j`u" #eqw d}.} .s5,m"! ,m.obj<: "<~n1"u $`=j5 #c ~n3;oef{"1 i.=.7"{ .<*s;m"( 8'0,,mnli,0 inohs `%eu"1 #dcc1jjj `) 8'0tra9 "6 dev "6 te/,0 .).n eg.7 .7"{"1 #aj.=w `ms_/ egs e1em7;o $,t eg.7 .m,? `=.}"1 i3o1 .7"{q 0,,snli4v i1"o" {5,} .)l" a#aa .n#a.7 #c4 #ce #a"1a irjv" *,teg" d*.o" %e} ,u,tn,s .).n"! ;m;&j5 #d ~n3;oef{"1 `vja .o1w{7ib .<*s;m"(8'0,,scitail,0 inohs `%eu"1 #bg1jjj `) .).n eg.7 .7"{"1 .m7`ui{7ja`+ `vja ~g> eg.n.ob $,t eg.7 .m,? `=.}"1 .o1eg`v #d.o ,)ij} `ra`v3,oa eg.n"! j5,`n #a`){"u j<:" .o1eg! $,t eg.7{"u $3.mj`u ,).o"! #aj`rw .).n eg.7{"u ~*j}j5 #e ~n3;oef{"1 .?ir.? .<*s;m"( 8'0,,anli,0 inohs `%eu"1 #afi1jjj `) 8'0tra9 "6 dev "6 te/,0 .).n eg.7 .7"{"1 `o.( e1em7;o_/~n3;oef{ $,t eg.7 .m,? `=.}"1 .m,?."! ,8jvoh{jrfs0'"u $3.mj`u euin1o ;mr>aj3 .?ir.? .<*s;m"( l"/"! e3i{cz :aj1! ~m:j5 =777777777777777777777777777777= :`o,s 0,,rte4cz ;<5`v `s.o' $,tw ~gdu"! #ej0p ir #ej0p "u h=.nj`u" c("o.? `v3`/n irj3 .m,?.7j3 .7"{w e1em7;on,s ~ui .?ir.?q l"/"! .n.aj<:/i4 o ~aan j5w ~g,?! jv1+7j3 .<*s;m"(8'0,,nli,0 }:an,sw ird+.?q .?ir.? l"/ *`m"u 0,,,anli `& hamlet8'0,nie et ;al4" #bjbj,0! i! ,m o/i4 o *`mn,scz `o.( 0,,nli4 inohs ,nh{w eg.n.s5! .o.?j<:/czin" .{a q`=.oc{7 euin1w ~1.) ,xiu"! `o.(w .<*sojr ~n3;oef{$ ,i"<$.o eu'j`u o/icz _soi4 `o.(w 0,,nlu4 ~n3;oef{"ucz ~uh= 0,,snli1 ,,sq,'u,,ad1 ,s5t,eval1 ,,glue4 i{7! i! ,m o/czin oi!o q$3w ojr c{7":an iui1jcz inncz `o1`ncz #ae c*8'0,,mni/,0" ,.1b`ncz #g c*8'0,image,net,0 .}iuw `o$3o ,u+iys/i4 `{ jm #bjah c* 0,,b}t4w i{7.7 ojmncz" o"sj3 0,,ai4 euin1i!o 0,,glue4v $8z ~n3;oef{n,s q$3 ,m.gw ojriun iui1jcz ,xiu$ erm ,~1"<.o`n iys/`u o"sj3 o%"u 0,sup},,glue4"<`u jcz ,r"ug ~n3;oef{$ i{7.7j`n iys/i4 ac `v* j*.rw ;y,q8'0/ate-(-!- >t,0 euin1i!o ,o1.n"u ~n3;oef{$ d}$"! ~9cz _se3f{5w .u0z ,}c{7! cr`u o/cz.ocz .r`uw :.o$ o/i4 .{a `o.(w ~n3;oef{n,s cu4z .s5,m"! ~9`u o/cz euin1i!o q$3o weo"! ojrjcz _s;s"s5 s,i) o1~3jv$ $c{7j3 ~7,oa{"u weo"! ojrjcz _so 7l7,ofo1 ,m o/iu"x cu":aj<:/i4 ;<5`u"u 0,,hamlet4w .asb `=.}z "8`{"o5#c01`v $8i8'0,nie et ;al41 #bjbj,04 "8`{"o5#c01 0,,hamlet4 .asb `=.} ,'`{"o5 ,r7">a,'"1 0,human-,&- ,model-9-!-,loop-,5tail;t ,tra9+4 ,iuj3 .?ir.? inohs"! h=jr jg"*! ,ofo1,m"x euin1w `*`u,}o j>7l7iy3icz .s5! ~u:.ms/{e:" 0,,anli4"! h=jr ja,{b,ofq euin1o c(eg ;&d3 i7,o"! `o.g{"u $.7 .u0z ,}c{7! ~u:/i4 o *`mn,s ,o1js5j3 0,,anli4 inohs ,nh{"! jv1+7j3 q`=.oc{7 )s euin1w d}$ `|`vcz "8`{"o5#d01v $8i8'0,nie et ;al41#bjbj,04 -----------------------------#ad "8`{"o5#d01 0,,anli4 inohs ,nh{"! h=j3 q`=.oc{7 )s euin1 d}$ `|`v =gggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg= 0,model ,tra9+ ,data3 ,,,a#a a#b a#c anli anli-;e snli,' ,,mnli-m_/-mm4 """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 0,,b}t ,s1 ,m"9#a3 #jj4j #bh4i #bh4h #ai4h #ai4i #ia4c #hf4g_/#hf4d "6,a#a3 #dd4b #cb4f #bi4c #ce4j #cd4b #ia4c #hf4c_/ #hf4e "6,a#a "6,a#b3 #eg4c #de4b #cc4d #dd4f #dc4b #ij4i #hf4c_/#hf4c "6,a "6,a#b "6,a#c3 #eg4b #di4j #df4a #ej4e #df4c #ij4i #he4f_/#he4d ;,,,s1 ;m1 ;f1 anli,'3 #eg4d #dh4c #dc4e #di4c #dd4b #ij4d #hf4j_/#he4h #ad .n#a.7 #c4 #da ,,xln,'et ;,,,s1 ;m1 ;f1 anli,'3 #fg4f #ej4g #dh4c #ee4a #eb4j #ia4h #hi4f_/#hi4d ,ro,,b}t,'a ;,s1 ;,m3 #dg4f #be4d #bb4a #ca4a #ca4d #ib4f #ij4h_/ #ij4f "6,f3 #ed4j #bd4b #bb4d #cb4h #cc4g #ib4g #ij4f_/ #ij4e "6,f"6,a#a"9#b3 #fh4g #ai4c #bb4j #ce4h #cf4h #ib4h #ij4i_/#ij4g "6,f"6,a#a"6,a#b"9#c3 #ga4b #dd4c #bj4d #dc4g #da4d #ib4i #ia4j_/#ij4g ;,,,s1 ;m1 ;f1 anli,'3 #gc4h #dh4i #dd4d #ec4g #di4g #ib4f #ia4j_/#ij4f =777777777777777777777777777777= e.oea{"u ;<5`uj1 e3j3 *`m"u 0,j9 et ;al48'#bjbj,0! i! ,m o/i4 o *`mn,siu .?ir.? l"/ inohs"! .<*s;s"o8'0,,nlp,0 euin1n ja,{bj<: euin1w ,}c{7 `r,)! ,oiuj<:/i4 o,ir .?ir.? l"/ inohs"! ja,{bj1 .<*s;s"o euin1"ucz 0,~w,,cnn1 ,~w,,l/m1 /&>d ,9f},s5t1 ,,esim" au 0,,b}t"<,bidirec;nal ,5cod} ,repres5ta;ns f ,trans=m}s">4 i{7o duj5iys/i4 0,,b}t4"! ~o"u'j3 :"s .<*s;s"o euin1w hna,{h{ ~g"%8'0classifica;n,0v j5w ~g,? `v.n8'0,,rte,0 ,mjr7n o/s,s :"s $.o inohs ,nh{"! jv1+7j<: .?ir.? l"/"! ja,{b ,of:/czin" j5w ~g,?! ,mjr7jcz `v.}n,s .?ir.? l"/"! jv1+7j<:/! ,ir 0/&>d ,9f},s5t1 ,,esim1 ,,b}t4 ,n euin1w .}jvaiu 8'0a3uracy,0$ f{`n ,its.q _s{"u chc/i4 ,iuj3 ,u,{ inohse3! jg"*,of:/! ,ir~ui .?ir.? l"/"! jg"*,of:/! ,ir 0,,mr4`v 0,,snli4 im `v.nw ,mjr7n o/s 0,,b}t4 euin1w `*`u,}8'0robu/;s,0o j>7l7iycz _s{"u i{"sc/i4 o *`mn,s i"m`u o/cz inohs ,nh{cz b#ad .n#a.7 #c4 #dc "8d+#d01v $8i4 -----------------------------#ae "8d+#d01 inohs ,nh{w `r+ =gggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg= `vsb8'0,task,0 inohs ,nh{ 8'0,dataset,0"1 jg"* `%eu 8'0,tra9,0 hn,{h{ `%eu 8'0,te/,0 d}`%3`o1o8'0,av}age ,l5g?,0 """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" ~g"%8'0,classifica;n,0 0,,ag's ,news"1 #cj0,k4 #a4i0,k4 #dc 0,fake ,news"1 #ah4h0,k4 #b0,k4 #hhe 0,,mr"1 #i0,k4 #a0,k4 #bj 0,,imdb"1 #be0,k4 #be0,k4 #bae 0,yelp"1 #efj0,k4 #ch0,k4 #aeb j5w8'0,5tail;t,0 0,,snli"1 #egj0,k4 #c0,k4 #h 0,multi,,nli"1 #dcc0,k4 #aj0,k4 #aa =777777777777777777777777777777= ,iuj3 "8d+#e01cz .?ir.? l"/v ~o`+ `|`v"! .}"oj3 _so`u" "8d+#f01z .?ir.? l"/"! ja,{bj3 `|`vv `{"s0.o <30z `}m 0,,b}t4w ,}c{7 ;0 0,,esim4 )seuin180,,snli ,multi,,nli"0 0,,b}t4 )seuin180,,snli ,multi,,nli "0 """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" ;y;u .}jvaiu8'0,orig9al ,a3uracy,0"1 8#hd4c4 #gj4i_/ #fi4f0 8#hf4e #gg4f_/#ge4h0 8#hi4d #he4a_/#hb4a0 .?ir.? ojm .}jvaiu80,af- ,attack ,a3uracy0"1 80#c4e #f4g_/#f4i0 80#e4a #g4g_/#g4c0 80#d4j #i4f_/#h4c0 0.0 ,p}turb$ ,~ws"1 8#ah4j a#ae .n#a.7 #c4 #de #ac4h_/#ad4f0 8'#ah4a #ad4e_/ #ad4f0 8#ah4e #ae4b_/#ad4f0 weo.? %l,}8'0,semantic ,simil>;y,0"1 8#j4ej #j4fa_/ #j4ei0 8#j4dg #j4ei_/#j4ei0 8#j4de #j4eg_/#j4eh0 .o1eg ,m8'0,qu}y ,numb},0"1 8#eg #gj_/#hc0 8#eh #gb_/#hg0 8#fj #gh_/#hf0 d}`%3 eg. `o1o8'0,av}age ,text ,l5g?,0"1 8#h #aa_/#ab0 8#h #aa_/#ab0 8#h #aa_/#ab0 =777777777777777777777777777777= "8d+#f01 .?ir.? l"/"! ja,{bj3 `}mv `{"s0.o <30z `}m 0,,b}t4w ,}c{7 ~o`+ =gggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg= `m~g"1 0,,mr4 )seuin180,af ,a3uracy ,p}turb$ ,~ws0 0,,snli4 )seuin180,af ,a3uracy ,p}turb$ ,~ws0 """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 0,orig9al"1 8#aa4e #af4g0 8#d4j #ah4e0 0"6,adv4 ,tra9+"1 8#ah4g #ba4j0 8#h4c #bj4a0 =777777777777777777777777777777= -----------------------------#ag +f)ir 0,,ai4w ~1i1z .<*s;s"o ~g>n,s ir`%eu .<*s ~n3;oef{w ~1i1n wjr ;x.qiys v/{c 0,,ai4w `{b,xj3 ~1i1 ,xiu"u qjr" .<*sojr ~n3;oef{i!z <4,s c$cz euin1w ,}c{7 j>7l7! ,i"<.b`o s":p.ocz l7jv7o iys/i4 o"sj3 l7jv7z .7`o$3 l+7 $c{7j3 ir`%euw ~n3;oef{ inohs ,nh{"! ,m.obj1 ,m o/!.on irj3 weg{"u os.:/{e:" j*.rw .<*s;s"o euin1o ,o1.n ~n3;oef{n,s ~uocz ,}c{7e3f{5 ,o1,n`/n,s .u0z ,}c{7! ~uo1 ,m o/cz.on irj3 wegiu .o,xiycz l7jv7oi4 ,iuj3 j*.r .(.rjcz ;y,qw euin18'0/ate-(-!->t,0i!z q$3o jcz _s;s"s5 %*j`u o1~3jviy3 weo ojrn ob$aj<: eg.n"! jr`|jcz _so a,}! ,`m.gjo ~1`*j`u" .o,x.?{"u jg"*j1 ,m o/`n iys/i4 j3d* euin1! ,xo`o mrj3 weojv+7.? ;m"( `v3`/"ucz ,mv >7 8'0num}ical`&quant,0" .o,ov e};o7 8'0ref}5ce`&"ns,0" d+.g 8'0/&>d,0" sjmr8'0lexical,0" ,xo5,m8'0tricky,0" ;m"( eo2 l,o18'0r1son+`&fact,0! l+7j<:/czin" o"sj3 ~7,oaz ~( `v.nn,siu .?`{a ~3}iys/i4 -----------------------------#ah .n#b.7 ,)jr7 i5jvw ;m;& -----------------------------#ai #a4 ,)jr7 i5jv ;m;& irl7 .?ir.? $,t! ,r7,}j`o mrj3 .).n$ iycz ,8,)jr7 i5jv0'cz `ma"ob`masp3w ,qeg e1em7;o #bjban,s ;m;&j<:/i4 o ,qeg e1em7;ocz euim #gbi1bhj`)w `ol"! duj5j`u o/{e: ;= #b4ie0,,gb4 ~g">7w inohsoi4 ,qeg e1em7;ow `m.ucz "8`{"o5#e01v $8i4 "8`{"o5#e01 `ma"ob`masp3 ,qege1em7;o #bjbaw 0,,json4 `m.u =gggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg= _7 81 "0 0,,json4 7 0id3 8,,nirw#aijjjjjjja0 _7 81 "0 0metadata4 7 0title"1 8`ma"ob`masp3 ,qeg e7em7;o 0,,nirw#aijjjjjjja0 7 0cr1tor"1 8`ma"ob`masp30 7 04tributor"1 8`ma"ob`masp3 7 0ye>3 8#bjai0 #ah .n#b.7 #a4 #di 7 0category"1 8,qeg 55 qhscn' `o~3 ,qeg0 _7 82 ;0 0annotation.-level4 7 #j"1 8p3,o0 7 0sampl+"1 8~m~g ;m;&- o5w;m;&0 _7 82 ;0 0docu;t4 _7 81 "0 #j 7 0id"1 8,,nirw#aijjjjjjja4a0 _7 81 "0 0metadata 7 0title"1 8ueagraph4 _7 81 "0 #j 7 0id3 8,,nirw#aijjjjjjja4a4a0 7 0from"1 88irh="}" ,o.7 ~7ege3 j.o e1`u ,o1;)jri1"<00 _7 81 "0 #a 7 0id3 8,,nirw#aijjjjjjja4a4b0 7 0from"1 8#bjjh c*w e.oea ,r~:a" )"(w fen"7jr/i4 ~7,=~sb i{7 .m+.r7.s5 ~sb<3o l7.}iy1 `majy ~(jyw.7! im`u :> wp3i!w .).r7! `oi"o`u o/s/i) _7 81 "0 #b 7 0id3 8,,nirw#aijjjjjjja4a4c0 7 0from"1 $8z ,o$a" `majy ~aa ,nl7n,s ,seqi!z `}.n mr`ov $7;mmr ,xn,s l15w `ui3 j5`v .};on irj3 .te7$5n ek,) ;r dadaj3 l15! os$`u o/s/i4 oi!w ex,u"o"! _7 81 "0 #c 7 0id3 8,,nirw#aijjjjjjja4a4d0 =777777777777777777777777777777= ,)jr7 i5jvw ;m;& irl7o ,qego" je:" cr+7.?{"ucz h{a.} .obi3n irj3 b#ai .n#b.7 #a4 #ea d*`*" %3"o.?{"u ~m.?.tj3 d+j* i{7o chc.o <30<> j3i4 -----------------------------#bj `ma"ob`masp3w ,qeg e1em7;o j},oaq 0,,json4z inohs cr+7`v `m.u"! j5,`n .s.7jcz d7j3 egj}`v sjmr$ duj5iy3 ,)jr7 i5jv"! ;m;&j`o mrjr,scz `%3j} .bjq hna,{h{ ,)~|o ,mjr7iys> j`o ,iregoi4 e).s ,)jr7 i5jv ;m;&z .i= o5w ;m;&! p3;oa{"u j<:/i4 oeo .)l3.?{"u ;s"oj`o ,mrg j}hr"u .n`=iy3 ,qeg e1em7;ow .7.s5! jv1+7jr i5jv ;m;&w .) `v.}! ,{f{"obh{"! h=jr .i= ;m;&je:" i<>7j3 }:aw `ol eg.7! l1d:~ue*,s .asbj1 ,m o/iu"x o5w"u ;m;&j<:/i4 i<{5{"u 80p>agraph0`>8=m0! .m7,o5{"u i5jv"! ;m;&j<:/i4 `m7`{a.?{"u .asb.cz .n,oiy3 ,)jr7 i5jv"! ~u`u .?ir.? $,t eg.7! ,r7,}j<:> j`o ,iregn o a#bj .n#b.7 #b4 #ec eg.7 .}~u"! $.q 0p>agraph4 j7exw 0=m4! .m7,o5{"u j<: ;y,uj3w cr+7! ;m;&j<:/i4 -----------------------------#ba ,n ~),.r" 0id4"! duj5j<: ;m;&jr,s ;m.?o $c{7jiu"x j<:/i4 0id4 .}~ucz .asbn .oa.sb.?q .}~u"! .n`=j.o <30.oe3" .m7~x ;m;& ~7.o eo2 ;mjm u"% ;m.? i{7w o%"u `{ j++7o q.}iys" egi3 0id4 .}~u"! j5,`n ;m;&jr cr~m.?{"u .s.7j<:/i4 e.oea{"u enhinohs 8'0metadata,0"! duj5j<: ;m;&j5{"u,,s i<>7j3 jv1+7o $c{7j`n j<:/i4 )"(l .}~u i{7! i5z enhinohscz 0id4v e;<3$.o"u .asbn .oa.sb.?q .}~u"! .n`=j.o <30{c" o"! ;m;&jr cr~m.?{"u .s.7jr ims ;a.?q ,g,scz <"rv $8i"1 82#a;0 0,,json4{"u `=%iy3 e1em7;o inohs d,o7 eo2 h=jb 82#b;0 $a e1em7;o dp>agraph0' .m7n,s o5w ;m;&iy3 irl7n irjr" 82#c-a;0 $8z ,80docu;t0' <3n,s" ;m;& irl7n ,)jr7jcz ,80docum5t`>p>agraph0'$ o/cz.o jvaq 82#c-b;0 ,)jr7 ,80docum5t`>p>agraph0'$ o/! `}m" ,80docum5t`>p>agraph`>id0'$ `o;m;& 0id4 ex"xn duj5iys/cz.o jvaq 82#c-c;0 eoduj5iy3 `}m ,80docum5t`>p>agraph`>id0'"! `o;m;& 0id4 ex"xn ;m$ a#ba .n#b.7 #c4 #ee -----------------------------#bb 82#c-d;0 irl7 ,80docum5t`>p>agraph`>=m0'! i=o1j3 ,80docum5t`>p>agraph0' <3n,s ,)jr7jcz j7ex`v j5,`n ,80docum5t`>metadata`>topic0'`v ,80docum5t`>p>agraph`>=m0'! ;m;&iy3 i5jv ex"xn ;m$ 82#d;0 ;m;&iy3 i5jv ex"xw ,80docum5t`>p>agraph`>=m0' cr+7! .asb.$ o1a`o ,mrg j}hr"u h=jb 82#e;0 h=jbiy3 cr+7! ,80docum5t`>metatdata`>=m0' .}~uv j5,`n prbl7w 0,my,,sql4 inohs~no,{n sb"ui{ 82#f;0 sb"ui{ iy3 irl7n irjr prb `o~3 pf{~n3;o"! h=jr j5w l"/ ,r7,} .asb .qjr7 ie3" `o.( inohsw ,80docum5t`>p>agraph0'cz eg,s .)~3n `t;: $a j7exw i3mr eo2 `o1on ;p>agraph0'n `olw .nex eo2 jni{"p>agraph0'w ;s' j7exo ,o1.n eg.7n duj5iy.o <30iu"x .u.tj<:/`u" `|`vn irjr,siu mrv $8z j%"o,{hoa! h=jr im `rw *,xiy3 eg.7{"u `m;maiyiu"x %iuj<:/i4 o"sj3 `v.}! iu,oajvje* "8`{"o5#f01`v $8i4 a#bb .n#b.7 #c4 #eg -----------------------------#bc "8`{"o5#f01 ,)jr7 i5jvw ;m;& `v.} =gggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg= 82,o.a;0 ~3o 82`ma"ob`masp3 ,qeg e1em7;o #bjba8'~s.) #a4j,00 ~3o 63333333333333333333333333333334 "8,nh{i7 #ij1jjj`) ;m;&01 820docum5t`>p>agrapf4o5w qina,{ ;m;&8';y;u #b`r j7ex .ny,099;0 ~3o 82era"p>agrapf`>.<,,=m1 ,,id.>docum5t`>metadata`>topic4 ;m;&;0 ~3o 82era" p>agrapf4o5w qina,{ ;m;&8';y;u #b`r j7ex .ny,099;0 ~3o inohs jva~u v3"+ 82.="+;0 =777777777777777777777777777777= o"sj3 `v.}! `s;: euim #g`rw "7w w`*,sn,s ;meor ~sbem~m .7`v3o eo1s~m8q o~) .oa.n`rd*<3! .}e* ~3~aj3 _s{"u <1":.:/ 0,,nrw#bajjjjjjjh4acaha4f .};o eq.mi7z `maeqwjo5 ~&;<5 ,xn .oc3 #bdo1 |"q ~sblmr ~sb<3,umrn,s .m7ir.rjr~sb<3n irj3 o1~m ,m.}o ~&$dojicz in w`*! eu j3icz e}~g ;{ae*n,s mmr"! .s5j1 _so"7`maw j:b":a ~7<3 i{7n c(wj3 ~ o/i4 0,,nrw#bajjjjjjjg4cicc4e ljy <1ein3io.7`v `}`oj:a,q,n3hs ;<7sb.op3 qd{"<"! `|jb" j3i4 irjv i{7 .sb;x! j.o <30cz _so $.7 .u0{c ~&$doj`n .sb;xjr> j3ie* t`&! ekir.o 0,,nrw#bajjjjjjjaj4cbdah4f ljy ocz .oc3 #hp1 ,8#h"2ae .objy0' ,ir;s"s5 ir`%eu"u ;<5$.i!o euocz .objycz j.o <30`n/icz o>`o"u" ;<">7 ,omrc #aq ,omrcz i7;u .g~oj3 ir"u .qjr7j1 0,,nrw#bajjjjjjjaj4biiic4d e#bc .n#b.7 #c4 #fc .};o i7.}o `|.}j3 #b;< .op3`{5w .o`{b ~7,oan l,o1l7 ~3`o"! iz ,n5oi4 o .ol$ ~ud* ~x.o"! c! .m.7j3 _s! $5<3jis"an i!s$3 ,8u1 c% <~3hn0'w ;s' c1 `/>air,m$ #a e3#eh ir"! `o"xjr/i`u ~1aj:/i4 0,,nrw#bajjjjjjja4eebf4h eo+7_/`)$7 i{"7 <3n,s o"ms.o`o ,iregn `s5l,o$3o #aqi7 .=.) #a =777777777777777777777777777777= -----------------------------#bd .n#c.7 .?ir.? $,t eg.7w ,r7,} -----------------------------#be #a4 .?ir.? $,t eg.7 ,r7,}! mrj3 .)">a ,)jr7 i5jv$ .?.tjo ;m;&iys/ie* `{i<{5 i3`/cz .?ir.? $,t eg.7! ,r7,}jcz i3`/oi4 .?ir.? $,t eg.7z `s5,m. $3w `s5hu"! `s;: `m7`{a.?{"u )s euin1! ,xocz in8'0fool+,0 ,}`=jr> j`o ,iregn $,t eg.7! ,r7,}jcz i3`/cz .asb.7j3 ;ra">a`v .asb jv3`}! e"*jr .mcz _so erm .m7+ji4 o lsbn,scz 0,nie et ;al48'#bjbj,0n,s .n,oj3 .?ir.? $,t eg.7 ,r7,}! mrj3 c("o.? `v3`/"! jj>7,oa{"u .?+7j<: $,t eg.7! i<>7j`n ,r7,}j1 ,m o/iu"x .asb.i!! `+%aj<:/{e:" i=,on .asb.$ ,mrb`n #bd .n#c.7 #a4 #fe l+7j1 ,m o/cz .asb+7 pf{~n3;o"! `r~1j<: jv1+7j<:/i4 8'#a,0 ,m">7 >7jv d+j* 0,num}ical `& ,quant4 7 $,t iu;& .)">a #a"1 ,m'.a #b"1 egeran,s .n,oiy3 .objb-~m~g.objb-:.objb $3w `v3`/"! jv1+7j<: ,xo`o -----------------------------#bf 82,)jr7 i5jv;0 cn'd!"oa,{cz eo`ma`v frcia #c"1 o1~3e}l jxz `u%e}lv l7ju;<5.ujcz ire}l"u ,m.}j<: ,xo`o 82,)jr7 i5jv;0 ix. :"s~g,`n,s )"(%3"ov )"(~sb.nw l7ju~u;m7,}`v l7juix"ob,}n is e30z `v3,o5o o/{,oie* .s.$ o ;ra`v j5,`n ,.a! o"mcz .s,&"u ~a}ln,s oeo ,8)"(~sb.n"(0'! ;&$3jr" .).}d3 #bf .n#c.7 #a4 #fg 8'.n#c d3_/#bjjg,0,$.o d:cr/{e{"u `{ ;ra! ;<5`uj<: o1as .m,o`o"! ~mhai{"qi4 ;raw ~mdo"! .u`{5o"d4 7 $,t iu;& .)">a #d"1 q`v.? c("o `v3`/"! o+7j<: ,xo`o 82,)jr7 i5jv;0 hra,o`oli!iu fu"uc :d"u ~ri1oc hra~r i{7{"u sb.=! .)jv3jr/i4 `{ `|`v hra,o ,m$ irdx $5,ujr/i4 82$,t;0 fu"uc :d o.)ncz ~ri1oc hra~r i{7{"uw sb.= .)jv3o sb's/i4 82j5w `v3`/;0 .m7"ob 8'0,neutral,0 82;m"(;0 j5w8'0,5tail;t,0 7 $,t iu;& .)">a #e"1 ~m.} `v3`/"! 0fool+4 82,)jr7 i5jv;0 `m"{5fdn egjal7 ,ml7.ob! :aa{e:" ca #f"1 ~o`+ `v3`/"! o+7j3 ,xo`o 82,)jr7 i5jv;0 as .t5zoi!z is c jcz i=,on ~9 j1 j*,o1oi4 ljy.?{"u q.}~9cz .u0z .oa.7e3o ..($5! cu4ocz `o1o a#bg .n#c.7 #a4 #fi a #g"1 i=ws jxz ~3ws `v3`/ $3w sjmr"! ,m.}j<: 0fool+4 /,o #a4 82,)jr7 i5jv;0 p1,{h{"oh{.sct 8'0,,wsj,0cz #ago18'j*.o,o$3,0 .oc3i1 eo c5~m `ma`}! h=jr ob`ma! ,oiuj3 oeq.,m$ #bb e3 #acjc e}o"<`u ~uiujr/i4 ocz #bb c*e3n `},qiy3 ;yir;o `o"xoi4 82$,t;0 eo c5~m `ma`}! h=jr ob`ma! v3"+j3 oeq.,m$ #bb e3 #acjc e}oi4 82j5w `v3`/;0 .m7"ob 8'0,neutral,0 82;m"(;0 eu,g8'0,3tradict,0 /,o #b4 82,)jr7 i5jv;0 ;< .o~m.7z `u":qi!w o10s~s"q egjvv )s"! iy;a #h"1 ~xjb e}l`m ,x i3s"! ,m.}j<: ,xo`o 82,)jr7 i5jv;0 ja #bg0p .{7$j3 _s{"u ~1aj:.:/i4 82$,t;0 ja #bg0p $5,ujr/i4 82j5w `v3`/;0 .m7"ob 8'0,neutral,0 82;m"(;0 eu,g8'0,3tradict,0 7 $,t iu;& .)">a #i"1 >asw `m,} +,u"! ~g"oj<: ,xo`o 82,)jr7 i5jv;0 .)eg$i!z 0,,mz4,nir8'eo1"ncot 5 0,z4,nir,0$ .<%"ub`u `r~7iy3 egjv"! ;m`mj3i`u ~g,?jr/i4 is'~m8:" oi!n`n `}.oaiy3 `=emp3 ljyw egjv$ `s~m$5! fo& ,m o/i`u .)jr/i4 82$,t;0 0,z4 ,nir$ ;m`mjcz egjvcz eo1"ncot ,nir$ ;m`mjcz egjvv `{ ,}`:ao i"{i4 82j5w `v3`/;0 eu,g 8'0,3tradict,0 82;m"(;0 j5w8'0,5tail;t,0 -----------------------------#cj 8'#e,0 ,xo5,m 0,tricky4 7 $,t iu;& .)">a #aj"1 `meg ~*jv3oc .r.}"|! h=j3 ,xo`o 82,)jr7 i5jv;0 `}c5iucz .oc3jr #abp1 #co1~mhs #aio1,$.o jv.r<3.)i{7`{bo ckz #ch`r ,o.7! irl7{"u ,u~7,s i{7`v jbi={"u jv.rir{7 ,o1hr .s5`s5! ~tq ~ o/i4 iucz .i=jv.r,x~u`o i{7 ,u~7,o,t .ai=%em"2,u~7,o,t .m~* .?;oe& ~7;o"2,u~7h="u eojva~u i{7! .m7.s5 .s5`s5jr/i4 82$,t;0 `}l7c5iucz .oc3jr *e1" jv.r<3.)i{7`{b! `o.g{"u j<:" o1~m ,o.7w jv.rir{7 ,o1hr"! .s5`s5jr/i4 82j5w `v3`/;0 j5w 8'0,5tail;t,0 82;m"(;0 .m7"ob8'0,neutral,0 8'#f,0 ;m"(`v l,o1 0,r1son+ `& ,facts4 7 $,t iu;& .)">a #aa"1 ,nl7w .o,oa eo2 l7,oa8'/"1 j3`maw o"{5 egjv,0"! l+7j<: ,xo`o #cj .n#c.7 #a4 #gc 82,)jr7 i5jv;0 #bjbj c* ;ucz fu"uc %jr7o ~(`:ajvj`o .oa.)os/i4 i7,o .oa.7q o5eu0cm" eu5em`n #fd0kg4{"u .}l7 ;n.m7n ,xjr/i4 82$,t;0 .oa.7q o5eu ,,ow ;q$cz o5,,o .ob<3oi4 82j5w `v3`/;0 j5w8'0,5tail;t,0 82;m"(;0 .m7"ob8'0,neutral,0 -----------------------------#ca #b4 .?ir.? $,t eg.7 ,r7,} `v.} <4 .tn,s .n<3j3 .?ir.? $,t eg.7! ,r7,}j`o mrj3 .)">az 0,nie et al4"<#bjbj"> ,,anli4 *`mw 0,bottom-up4 j}hr"! ~*+7j3 _s{"u,s" 0,top-d{n4 j}hr"! ,i"z _soi4 o"sj3 `s,o.?q .)">an ,i"< i<{5`v $8z ,n~m.?q .t;<"! `s;:,s .?ir.? $,t eg.7w ,r7,} `v.}o .qjr7iy3i4 8'#a,0 #f`rw ;m"( ~7,oan `z`sj3 .o;o5 ,m"ob8'.o;o5w ,n~m cr+7z "8~m"x01! ;<5.u,0 8'#b,0 .asb. ,o1,{b `+%a 8'#c,0 .o;o5n ,i"< .?ir.? $,t eg.7 ,r7,} 8'#d,0 .asb. $3 `s5,m 8'#e,0 .?ir.? l"/"! euin1n ob":aj<: ,xo`o8'0fool+,0 hn,{h{ 8'.asb.$ ~m; j3i4 8'#b,0 q`=.oc{7 euin1z h{a.}j3 o1~3l7,oao `|:iys o/i4 3o c ,xo`on ,}`=j1 $c{7,}ofs.qi4 8'#d,0 q`=.oc{7 euin1z ,r7">aiy3 e}l`mw ~xp3n s":m5! `:aa! ,m o/i4 3o ,r7">aiysiu ~xp3 $c{7j3 e}l`mw `}m" $,tn,s o"! ,r7">ajr,s .n,oje* ,xo`on ,}`=j1 $c{7,}o cu4<.qi4 8'#e,0 q`=.oc{7 euin1z z%c jv3%"! ojrjcz inn s":m5! `:aaczi4 3o era",ref}5ce`&,"ns "< ">,/&>d "< ">,lexical "<,v">,tricky "<,v">,r1son+`&,facts4 `v3`/"1 8'0,v,0j5w8'#ed4dg0p,0 8' ,0.m7"ob8'#cj4jg0p,0 8' ,0eu,g8'#ae4df0p,0 """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" ,te}"1 jva.q."! h=jr ,me30z eo1.sb.sb;x.$ ~1,r7j1 mrjs5,}n b#cc .n#c.7 #b4 #gi irjr e1j`u o/{e{"u jva.q.7 `o.g.od+ .m7 jc7iy1 $c{7,}o cu4<.:/i4 82"<~n1;0 0,e4 82,te};0 ljy.? `s"oim`o #b i3`/ l7j>7 `o.g.od+"! b#da .n#d.7 #b4 #ie ;m7.xj<:/{e{"u #b i3`/"u l7j>7iy1 $c{7,}o cu4<.q _soi4 82;m"(;0 0/&>d1 tricky4 820,,klue-,ro,,b}t,'a base4 /;{a "<~n1;0 0,n4 820,,krb}t4 "<~n1;0 0,n4 82,xo`o ,}`= :~m;0 ,}`= 7 82i5jv;0 `|`ma .rd3~mcz #go1 .) exln irj3 ~u,?! ;mr,uj`u ,s&`m;o,un .r,m$5jcz `|.}! cr":/i4 .rd3~mcz 8j}l,u,=~sb .n#ajb.u .n#b j7 .n#e ju ,8~sbp3o .}j3 .u`)! mr~3j3 ,ir0'n jri7jcz l%$ o/i0e: 8do`uqn irj3 ~u,?! ;mr,uj`u ~u,? ~u.{7`{5 .m7 #cjjj e3p3! eu1;mrj3i0`u ~1aj:/i4 82$,t;0 .) exlcz #cjjj e3p3 ol7w ~u,? ~u.{7`{5! cr/i4 82"<~n1;0 0,e4 82,te};0 ~u,? ~u.{7`{5 .m7 #cjjj e3 p3! eu1;mrj3i`u j<:/{e{"u" .) exlcz `{ ol7w `{5ra! ~u,? ~u.{7`{5{"u cr3 .?o o/{5! ;m"(j1 ,m o/i4 82;m"(;0 0/&>d1 tricky4 820,,klue-,ro,,b}t,'a base4 /;{a "<~n1;0 0,n4 820,,krb}t4 "<~n1;0 0,e4 82,xo`o ,}`= :~m;0 ,o1dr -----------------------------#dc 8'#b,0 .m7"ob 7 82i5jv;0 ,m,oeu.ob p3,s .sb,m o1.}z .)`maw euiz .)egir$ i=o1j`n g}iy3i4 .)j}`o$3 cr e*.sb ,o1,o i{7w `ul o1.}z $a irjao .<%1.?{"u .}j`u irja $3 ~x,m.op3 eo2 obja .op3 jy',miu .nj3o sb'i4 82$,t;0 ,m,oeu.ob p3,s .sb,m o1.}z .)`maw euiz irja`+n,s i=o1j`n g}iy3i4 82"<~n1;0 0,n4 82,te};0 ,m,oeu.ob p3,s .sb,m o1.}z .)`maw euiz .)egirn,s i=o1j`n g}iy.oe3 euiz irja`+n,siu `{").ocz <1 ,m sb'{e{"u .m7"obn jri7j3i4 82;m"(;0 0,r1son+1 tricky4 820,,klue-,ro,,b}t,'a base4 b#db .n#d.7 #b4 #ig /;{a "<~n1;0 0,e4 820,,krb}t4 "<~n1;0 0,e4 82,xo`o ,}`= :~m;0 ,}`= 7 82i5jv;0 m,) duj7,ocz .oc3jr #abp1 duj7`v "s,o< ~!"d4 820,,klue-,ro,,b}t,'a base4 /;{a "<~n1;0 0,e4 820,,krb}t4 "<~n1;0 0,n4 82,xo`o ,}`= :~m;0 ,o1dr 8'#c,0 eu,g 7 82i5jv;0 on ,mc{7 c3oiu .u.}n irj3 +`miu cu4<.ocz eu>7,ri4 .)`ma,oiu`+%a$5j:bwjycz ucz #io1 ;m7c5n,s ;=jy"! |`u u1jr ,mc{7 c3oiu .u.} i{7 `u#c .rja,r7! ,o1.o1.?{"u .op3j1 ,m o/cz ~7<3n irjr c(wj1 /.}oi4 82$,t;0 .)`ma,oiu`+%a$5j:bwjycz u1jr ,mc{7 c3oiu .u.} ~7<3! jva.}j<:/i4 82"<~n1;0 0,c4 82,te};0 .)`ma,oiu`+%a$5 j:bwjycz u1jr ,mc{7 c3oiu .u.} ~7<3 i{7! c(wj1 /.}oe{"u" o"! jva.}j<:/icz _sz eu,gn jri7j3i4 82;m"(;0 0/&>d1 tricky4 820,,klue-,ro,,b}t,'a base4 /;{a "<~n1;0 0,n4 820,,krb}t4 "<~n1;0 0,n4 82,xo`o ,}`= :~m;0 ,}`= 7 82i5jv;0 ,s&w fu"uc#ai ,q`% jva.q.cz #aho1 j"m #ad e}o c!sc #aio1 #j,o `o.g cm.? #e1gjb e}{"u .ob`/ivr/i4 ,r"ug a#dd .n#d.7 #b4 #ii .obi3$5:5z sb's/`u" .qjr7 .m7q .obi3$5:5 l"/q iu~=`m ic~}p3 `v3"* #b e}8'jv3. #b e},0" ,=d`m .5)w"+`o eo2 $7c5`m fu1,n3hs `v3"* #b e}o c7l7n `o:j1 ,m o/! _soi8'"8d+#ai01,04 -----------------------------#df "8d+#ai01 #a--#g"ge"1 #ccg0,m4 0,,klue-,ro,,b}t,'a base"1 #aaj0,m4 0,ko,,electra-,base-v#c8'oj 0,ko,,electra,0"1 #aab0,m4 0,,krb}t"1 #ii0,m4 0,,klue-,,b}t"1 #aaj0,m4 =777777777777777777777777777777= $,tw .?ir,} `s5.{7z i<{5`v $8z `v.}{"u .qjr7iys/i4 -----------------------------#di e).s" `o.(w j3`mas 0,,nli4 inohs ,nh{8'0,,klue-,,nli,0"! $.o`u eo,n.u.}iy3 euin1i!o .r`s5,m .asb! `s;o`o o.)w ;= #ba1cjj`)w 0,,anli4 inohs ,nh{n irjr sc{ .}iuw ,}c{7! ~uocz.o jvaqj<:/i4 im ~),.r"u" `o.( j3`mas 0,,nli4 inohs ,nh{"! $.o`u eo,n.u.}iy3 euin1i!`v 0,,anli4"! $.o`u eo,n.u.}! .qjr7j3 euin1i!o 0,,anli4 inohs ,nh{n ~uocz ,}c{7! ~o`+j<:/i4 e.oea{"u" 0,,anli4"! $.o`u eo,n.u.}! .qjr7j3 euin1i!o `o.( j3`mas 0,,nli4 inohs ,nh{n s,isj3 ,}c{7! ~uocz.o d}$jiu"x j<:/i4 7 ,o1js5 ~r`}`v `oir o~) .?ir.? j5w ~g,? inohs ,nh{w `o~3o iy3 *`m8'0,nie et ;al4" #bjai,0n,sv e;<3$.o"u" `m;maiy3 inohs ,nh{w dm5.o1! `s5.{7j`o mrj<: d}$ ,o1js5! .qjr7j<:/i4 o~) lsbw .m7+ i=`o .m7 jccz j*.r ~n3;oef{w `r~1 ,xiu$ )s euin1w `{b,xj3 ~1.) ,xiu"! ,i"<.b.o eu'j`u o/icz _sos/i8'0,nie et ;al4" #bjbj,04 .{a" o~) lsb! h=jr `m;maiy3 0,,anli4$ .?.tj3 ~7,oa`v .t;<"! a#di .n#e.7 #a4 #ajg h=jr `m;maiy`u `s5,m$ o"ms.:/ie*" j*.r )s euin1`v <4{"u i{7.7j1 )s euin1w d}$$ $c{7jiu"x `o.( .<*s;m"( inohs ,nh{n ~ojr `{ c3iu$ cu4<> j1 _soi4 ,iuj3" 0,,anli4cz .?ir.? ~7~sb"(! jv1+7j<:/i4 .?ir.? l"/"<3" q`=.oc{7 euin1w >a.s5! `=">aj1 ,m o/cz l"/"! o1fs9cz _s{"u q`=.oc{7 )s euin1i!o ~n3;oef{ inohs ,nh{n .(.rjcz h=`/.? d*j>7! ~m.?.tj`n ja,{bj`sc jv1+7jcz _s! ea! _soi4 o~) lsbn,scz `m;ma `v.}n,s inohsw .?ir,}! jvaqj`o mrjr euin1 ,xo`o ~7,oa! .?+7j3 ~ o/i4 e3>a" 0,,anli4 inohs ,nh{w `m;man o/s .?ir.? ~7~sb"(o .?.tj`n .?+7iys/ie*" inohs ,nh{w .?ir.?q c3iuvcz ~|`r"u euin1 ,xo`on jv1+7iy3 euin1i!z h{ajo is ckz ,}c{7! ~u:.ms> j1 _soi4 -----------------------------#ej o im $.o `v3.s5n,s" e3>a 0,,anli4$ .?.tj`n `m;maiys/ie* ;s' ~),.r d}$n,s `o.( inohs ,nh{"! h=jr eo,n.u.}o .qjr7iy3 euin1i!z 0,,anli4n erm ckz ,}c{7! ~u:> je: ,iuj3" euin1 d&"o7n jv1+7iy3 0,,klue- ,ro,,b}t,'a base4v 0,,krb}t4cz 0,,anli4n irjr i"z euin1~uiiu jp1,,q ,its.ocz ,}c{7! ~u:> j3i4 7 j3`mas q`=.oc{7 euin1 `r~1nw jv1+7 $c{7,},)jr7 *`mn,s euin1w ja,{bo .?ir.? l"/"! `o~3{"u j3 ~n3;oef{ inohs ,nh{"! h=jr o"ms.q `}m euin1w `*`u,}o j>7l7iy`u `vsb ,mjr7w ;{ae*n,siu `r,)iy3 ,}c{7! ~u:.ms/i4 .{a" `o.( inohs ,nh{n ~ojr ,8.?ir,}0'! jv1+7j3 0,,anli4 inohs ,nh{$ j3`mas q`=.oc{7 euin1w ,}c{7 `r~1n `o:j1 ,m o/! _s{"u `oiriy3i4 o"sj3 $c{7,}! o1~m jvaqj`o mrjr,scz" 0,,anli4 inohs ,nh{"! h=jr eo,n.u.}! .qjr7j3 euin1i!o inohs ,nh{"! h=jr eo,n.u.}o .qjr7iy3 a#ej .n#e.7 #a4 #aji euin1i!~ui `r,)iy3 ,}c{7! ~u:> j3i4 :`on isjr" 0,,anli4 inohs ,nh{"! h=jr eo,n.u.}! .qjr7j3 euin1i!o `o.( inohs ,nh{n irjr,siu `r,)iy3 ,}c{7! ~u:> j1 _soi4 7 eo.n.u.}8'0f9e-tun+,0 eo2 d}$ inohs #e`rw euin1n irjr $a$a im .="%w inohs ,nh{"! jv1+7j<: eo,n.u.}! .qjr7j<:/i4 o .m7 j3 inohs ,nh{cz `o.(n .?ir.? ~7~sb"(! jv1+7j.o <30z ~7,oa{"u `m;maiy3 0,,klue-,,nli4 inohs ,nh{" ces.o j3 inohscz o~) lsb! h=jr `m;maiy3 0,,anli4 inohs ,nh{"! jv1+7j<:/i4 0,,klue-,,nli4 inohs ,nh{ 8'0,p>k et ;al4" #bjba,0 .m7" jg"* inohs #bd1iih`)`v `r~1 inohs ,nh{ #c1jjj`)! jv1+7j<: #e`r euin1n irj3 eo,n.u.}! .qjr7j<:/i4 0,,anli4inohsw `}m" ,r7,} jm `s5,m"! h=`vj3 #ch1jah`)w inohs .m7" 0,,klue- ,,nli4 inohs"! h=jr eo,n.u.}j3 0,,klue-,ro,,b}t,'a base4v 0,,krb}t4"! ,xoczin euim ,}`=j3 inohs #ba1cjjw inohs"! $.o`u ,o1js5! .qjr7j<:/i4 -----------------------------#ea o,ir" .);n #ba1cjj`)w inohscz ja,{b" `s5.{7" ,ojs5! $a$a #h"1a"1aw ~o%1"u ccms jv1+7j<:/i4 .{a" ;y.= .?ir,} `s5.{7n,s #e`rw euin1! ja,{b,ofoczin l+7iy3 inohscz #ba1cjj`)w #hj0pn jri7jcz #ag1jdj`)oi4 oi! $a$aw ,n~m.?q cr+7z "8d+#ba01`v $8i4 "8d+#ba01 #e`r euin1 ja,{bn jv1+7iy3 inohs ,n~m cr:a =gggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg= `m~g"1 81_|0,tra9_|1 _|,dev_|1 _|,te/_|"0 p3eg inohs eg;n """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 0,,klue-,,nli"1 #bdiih" #cjjj" #cjjj c%,{" mrfodoio<" "o~% `ms" egs c#ej .n#e.7 #a4 #aaa 0,,anli"1 #agjdj" #bacj" #bacj c%,{ egs =777777777777777777777777777777= 7 d}$ d}$ncz eo,n.u.} ,on jv1+7iy3 im `rw inohs ,nh{n,s ;= ,n .="%w jk et ;al4" #bjba,0" :`on isjr im inohs ,nh{n .(.rjcz "<~n1 $3 ~&`%3j}n ir{7j`o mrj<: 0,f#a .s5,m ,iuj3 b#ea .n#e.7 #a4 #aac d}$ `o.g{"u jv1+7j<:/i4 7 ,o1js5 `|`v e).s" 0,,anli4 inohs ,nh{n irjr `o.( j3`mas 0,,nli4 inohs ,nh{8'0,,klue-,,nli,0"! $.o`u eo,n.u.}iy3 euin1i!o ~uocz ,}c{7! jvaqj<:/{e: `{ `|`vcz "8d+#bb01v $8i4 -----------------------------#ec "8d+#bb01 `o.( j3`mas 0,,nli4 inohs8'0,,klue-,,nli,0"u eo,n .u.}iy3 euin1w ,}c{7 =gggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg= euin1"1 eo,n.u.} inohs 0,,anli4 .);n80,f#a .}jvaiu0 """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 0,,klue-,ro,,b}t,'a l>ge"1 0,,klue-,,nli4 8#ad4aa #ab4ga0 0,,klue-,ro,,b}t,'a base"1 0,,klue-,,nli4 8#j4jj #j4jj0 0,ko,,electra-,base-v#c"1 0,,klue-,,nli4 8#aa4cj #aa4bd0 0,,krb}t"1 0,,klue-,,nli4 8#j4jj #j4jj0 0,,klue-,,b}t"1 0,,klue-,,nli4 8#aa4dj #aj4hi0 =777777777777777777777777777777= `s5.{7! .qjr7j3 `|`v" euin1w d"ge4 euin1w .s5,m.u;< $a$a .}jvaiu #ab4ga" 0,f#a .s5,m #ad4aa"u erm ckz ,m.gw ,}c{7! ~u:.ms/i4 ac $.7 fz euin1q e3f{5 i"z euin1~uicz l7ir.?{"u cu4z .s5,m"! ~u:.ms/i4 ac 0,,anli4 `m;maw ,xo`o `v.}n jv1+7iy3 0,,klue-,ro,,b}t,'a base4v 0,,krb}t4w `}m" .}jvaiuv 0,f#a.s5,m euimn,s #j.s5! ~u:.ms/i4 a#ec .n#e.7 #a4 #aae `{i<{5 `v.}{"u 0,,klue-,,nli4v 0,,anli4w jg"* inohs"! h=jr eo,n.u.}! .qjr7j3 euin1i!o $8z 0,,anli4 ,ojs5 inohs ,nh{n irjr ~uocz ,}c{7! ~o`+j<:/{e: `{ `|`vcz "8d+#bc01`v $8i4 -----------------------------#ed "8d+#bc01 0,,klue-,,nli4v 0,,anli4w jg"* inohs"u eo,n.u.}! .qjr7j3 euin1i!w ,}c{7 =gggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg= euin1"1 eo,n.u.} inohs 0,,anli4 ,ojs580,f#a .}jvaiu0 """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 0,,klue-,ro,,b}t,'a l>ge"1 0,,klue-,,nli4 8#ae4gj #ad4df0 0,,klue-,ro,,b}t,'a base"1 0,,klue-,,nli4 8#j4jj #j4jj0 0,ko,,electra-,base-v#c"1 0,,klue-,,nli4 8#aj4if #aj4he0 0,,krb}t"1 0,,klue-,,nli4 8#j4jj #j4jj0 0,,klue-,,b}t"1 0,,klue-,,nli4 8#aa4ec #aa4ac0 0,,klue-,ro,,b}t,'a l>ge"1 0,,anli4 8#fa4hc #gc4ga0 0,,klue-,ro,,b}t,'a base"1 0,,anli4 8#eb4hd #fg4hi0 0,ko,,electra-,base-v#c"1 0,,anli4 8#eg4hc #fh4hg0 0,,krb}t"1 0,,anli4 8#ee4hi #fh4ca0 0,,klue-,,b}t"1 0,,anli4 8#eh4eh #gj4bh0 =777777777777777777777777777777= ,}c{7 d}$"! .qjr7j3 `|`v" 0,,klue-,,nli4"! h=jr eo,n.u.}! .qjr7j3 euin1i!z 0,,anli4 jg"* inohs"! h=jr eo,n.u.}o .qjr7iy3 euin1i!n ~ojr erm ,its.ocz ,}c{7! ~u:/i4 e).s 0,,klue-,,nli4"! h=jr eo,n.u.}! .qjr7j3 euin1w `}m" `m;ma `v.}w .?ir,} `s5.{7n l+7iy3 0,,klue-,ro,,b}t,'a base4v 0,,krb}t4"! .nyje* o1~3.?{"u #aa.s5n,s #af.s5 low .s5,m ~gdu"! ~uo`u o/i4 ~3e*" 0,,anli4 jg"* inohs"! h=jr eo,n.u.}o .qjr7iy3 a#ed .n#e.7 #a4 #aag euin1i!z" 0,f#a .s5,m .m7 $.7 ckz .s5,m$ #eb4hd" .}jvaiu .m7 $.7 ckz .s5,m$ #fg4hio1 e3f{5 `o.( inohs"! h=jr eo,n.u.}o .qjr7iy3 inohsi!n ~ojr p1i{7jo cu4z ,}c{7! ~u:.m`u o/i4 -----------------------------#ee ac 0,,anli4"! h=jr eo,n.u.}o .qjr7iy3 inohsi! ,iuj3 ,imrsc3 ,}c{7! ~u:.m`u o/.ocz eu'jr/i4 `o.(n 0,,klue-,ro,,b}t,'a l>ge1 ,,klue-,ro,,b}t,'a base" au 0,,klue-,,b}t4cz 0,,klue-,,nli4 inohs ,nh{n irjr,s .}jvaiu$ $a$a #hi4ag" #hd4hc" #ha4fc{"u" euim #hj.s5o cs5cz ,}c{7! ~u:/i 8'0,p>k et ;al41 #bjba,04 on ~ojr 0,,anli4 inohs ,nh{w `}m" .}jvaiuw ;y`u.s5o 0,,klue- ,ro,,b}t,'a l>ge4w #fc4ga.s5{"u #hj.s5! ;r cs5`o.o eu'j`u #gj.s5ir ;u~3n ese&"s o/s/{e:" i"z euin1i!z euim #gj.s5! cs5`o.o eu'jcz l7i7jo ckz .s5,m ~gdu"! chcr/i4 ;m$.?{"u" 0,,anli4"! h=jr eo,n.u.}! .qjr7j3 euin1! irl7{"u 0,,klue-,,nli4 inohsn irj3 ,}c{7 d}$"! .qjr7j<:/{e: `{ `|`vcz "8d+#bd01v $8i4 "8d+#bd01 0,,anli4"u eo,n.u.}! .qjr7j3 euin1w ,}c{7 d}$ =gggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg= euin1"1 eo,n.u.} inohs 0,,klue-,,nli80,f#a .}jvaiu0 """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 0,,klue-,ro,,b}t,'a l>ge"1 0,,anli4 8#ad4hg #ae4cc0 0,,klue-,ro,,b}t,'a base"1 0,,anli4 8#ad4ce #ae4ia0 0,ko,,electra-,base-v#c"1 0,,anli4 8#ad4eg #ad4ce0 0,,krb}t"1 0,,anli4 8#ag4ac #ag4ee0 0,,klue-,,b}t"1 0,,anli4 8#af4fj #af4dc0 =777777777777777777777777777777= a#ee .n#e.7 #a4 #aai on ,i"{e* 0,,anli4"u eo,n.u.}! .qjr7j3 euin1i! ,iuj3 .)~3.?{"u #ad.s5n,s #ag.s5 low #aj.s5ir .m7~3w .s5,m l7ir.?{"u ,its.ocz ,}c{7! ~u:/i4 `{.m7 $.7 .u0z ,}c{7! ~u:.g euin1z 0,,krb}t4"u 0,f#a .s5,mv .}jvaiu euim #ag.s5! cs5cz $.7 cu4z .s5,m"! ~u:.ms/i4 -----------------------------#ef ac ocz i"z euin1i!w ,}c{7o ;m7~gj.o eu'j`o ,ireg{"u" l7ir.?{"u cu4`n ;{a.}iy3 o"sj3 ,}c{7o %weoji`u ~u`ocz s":bi4 e&"( 0,,klue-,,nli4"u eo,n.u.}! .qjr7j<: 0,,anli4 inohsn irj3 ,}c{7! jvaqjr/i) `|`v~uicz j>7l7iy3 `|`v"! ~u:.m`ocz j<:/i4 -----------------------------#eg #b4 ,o1js5 `|`vw jr,? ;s' ~),.r d}$v im ~),.r d}$n,s euim" euin1w d"a.s5! ;m7~gjo jv1+7jcz ~7j>7{"u 0,,anli4$ `m;maiys/{5! .1 ~u:.mcz _soi4 7 0,,anli4n irj3 euin1 ,}c{7w `}j>7 ;s' ~),.rv im ~),.r d}$ eo,n.u.} inohsv d}$ inohsn l7`v3sb'o" euim d"ge4 euin1o $.7 cu4z ,}c{7! ~u:.ms/i4 -----------------------------#eh ocz )s euin1 d}$w }:an,s o1~3.?{"u `oiriycz `|`voi4 i=,on" euin1w .="%n l7`v3sb'o 0,,anli4n irjr,scz .)~3.?{"u ckz .s5,m"! ~u:/i4 j3d* `s5.{7n l+7iy3 #e`rw euin1z f{`n 0,,b}t4 `o~3 euin1" 0,,electra4 `o~3 euin1" 0,,rob}ta4 `o~3 euin1"u ccms ~u1 ,m o/i4 i<>7j3 .="%w euin1o `s5.{7n l+7iys/.oe3" `o.( inohs ,nh{"! h=jr eo,n.u.}o o"ms.q `}m `{ .="%n l7`v3sb'o .)~3.?{"u #ae.s5! cs5.o eu'jcz ckz ,}c{7! ~u:.ms/i4 .{a" `m;ma `v.}n,sw euin1 ,xo`o i3`/ncz 0,,klue- ,ro,,b}t,'a base4v 0,,krb}t4w im euin1! jv1+7j<:/.oe3" o im euin1,~ge3 7j3 7j3 euin1i!w ,}c{7 d}$n jv1+7iy1 ,m o/cz $7`),}! $k;g inohs ,nh{"7z" .<*s ;m"( inohsw o1~3jv $c{7,}`v *`v3o o/cz _s{"u jr,?j1 ,m o/czin" on irjr,scz j>7jm *`m$ .o,xiy1 do1+$ o/! _soi4 -----------------------------#ei #c4 .egjyw"! h=j3 ;y.= `s5hu ~( lsbw `|`vq j5w ~g,? e1em7;ocz q`=.oc{7! ~o"u'j<: i<>7j3 }:an,s `o;u .7,}" jva.7 eo2 jv1+7 $c{7,} i{7n irj3 y~m .)eg$i!w .eg! `mjcz `v.}o do1+ji4 ~( lsbn,scz ja`/v l3sb`/n,s v7,}j`n jv1i=j`u o/cz #e e}w .egmrp3i3! `ma"ob`masp3`v j5,`n `m,}j`u #ajp1`v #abp1" im ;<"/n `t;: .egjyw"! ,o1,oj5{"u,,s e1em7;ow ,q"y,}`v .}jva,}" ~s5+7,} i{7! `r,)j`u. j<:/i4 #ajp1n |"q .egjywcz ("7w ~o%1z s,is0`n `m,}j`u o/c{c>cz .egi3w w`*,0 - ,8,te}0' ~m~gn irj3 .a,}! .u5 is .}`+jvj1 do1+$ o/icz .egi3w .u) - euin1w ,xo`o8'0fool+,0n o/s ir`%eu )s euin1! irl7{"u ,mjr7j<:/cz.on irj3 .o.?8'ir`%eu )s euin1o duj5iys o/s> j3i`u .u)jr .ms/{e:" lsbi3n,scz o"! jvaqj<:/{5,0 - ,xo`ow ,}`= ~o%1`v on ,i"z .asb">7 `/l3! .?.tjo :5imn im`u o/cz.on irj3 jvaq .u) - ,)jr7 i5jv$ euim ,qeg `ol"u j3.}iys o/icz _sn irj3 eg.n"! `u":j`u o/s> j3icz .u)" au ,na,*~|"u s,is0`n ,)jr7 i5jv"! `m,}j<:/cz.oiu `u":jr> j3i`u .o.?j54 - .)~3.?q lsbw ~7j>7,}`v `|`vn irjr,scz euim `{7.}.?q ~3{7 -----------------------------#fj _7 #b;< .egjyw8'#bjbc c* #abp1" ,se*.ul j},oa{"u .qjr7,0 - #a;< .egjywn,s erm l7,nj`n w`*! `=%j<:/`u" lsbi3n,siu .egmrp3i3w .u)! .?`{a ,m+7j<: lsb! .qjr7j3 `|`v #b;< .egjywcz ,se* j},oa{"u $3">ajo .qjr7j<:/{54 - #a;< .egjywn,s jx,o cm"7! .& ,m o/`o ,irego"<`u j54 j3d* ;y.= `=`r d7j3 ~g>w *`m.i!o jv1+7j`o .u0! _so"ajo +>aj`u" j>7jm `v.n"! .n)jcz _s{"u `|"(! l5`u. j3i4 #a4 +>a ~( lsbz j3`mas q`=.oc{7w `vsb ,mjr7 c{7":a o1~3`v cu4z l7`v3`v3`/"! $k`u o/cz )s ;m"(q ,8j5w ~g,?0'! mrjr ,qeg hna,{h{"u~mhs ,)jr7 i5jv"! ;m;&j`u" o"! `o~3{"u .?ir.? l"/"! ,r7,}j<: q`=.oc{7 d}$+7 ~n3;oef{"u $`=j5{"u,,s .<*s ojr ~n3;oef{w ;mr>a,} eg.n"! ~uv3j`o mrj3 ~7<3! e"*jcz in ex.?o o/i4 o"! mrjr #bjba c* `ma"ob`masp3 ,qeg e1em7;o"u~mhs #g;<"/w "a! `o~3{"u j3 `m;ma .o;o5! ,m"obj<: .?+7j<:/`u" .asbw j+%1,}! ;yirj3{"u cu4o`o mrjr,s .asb+7 ~n3;oef{"! `r~1" jv1+7j<:/i4 o"! h=jr euim #ec1bad`rw .?ir.? $,t! ,r7,} j<:/i4 j3d* ,r7,}iy3 .?ir.? $,tz ;m"( d3i3w .}jva,}! mrjr #b e}w .asb.7,}! euim `{a~xjr/i`u ~u`oncz j3`/$ o/i4 j>7jm *`mn,scz ,)jr7 i5jvw ;m;& irl7 hna,{h{"! isma i<>7j`n jva.7j5{"u,,s )s euin1w ~s5+7,}`v $7`),}! $7jvjcz in ium5o iy1 _soi4 j3d* #b e3: `)w .?ir.? $,t! ,r7,}" `s5,mj`u ~x,mw )s euin1! irl7{"u ,xo`o ,o1js5,$.o ,mjr7jcz o1"*w `v.}z erm ~x.bj`u e30z i3`/$ do1+j1 ,~g k1 ;,p41 ,dagan1 ,i41 `& ,giampi3olo1 ;,d4 "<#bjji">4 ,! ,fif? ,,pascal ,recogniz+ ,textual ,5tail;t ,*all5ge4 ,9 ,,tac4 ,bos1 ;,j41 `& ,m>k}t1 ;,k4 "<#bjje">04 ,recognis+ textual 5tail;t ) logical 9f};e4 ,9 ,proce$+s ( ,human ,language ,te*nology ,3f};e & ,3f};e on ,empirical ,me?ods 9 ,natural ,language ,process+ "4 ,b{man1 ;,s4 ;,r41 ,angeli1 ;,g41 ,potts1 ;,c41 `& ,mann+1 ;,c4 ;,d4 "<#bjae">4 ,a l>ge annotat$ corpus = le>n+ natural language 9f};e4 ,9 ,,naacl4 ,3doravdi1 ;,c41 ,cr|*1 ;,d41 ,de ,paiva1 ;,v41 ,/olle1 ;,r41 `& ,bobr{1 ;,d4 "<#bjjc">4 #fd ;<5`uegj) #ace ,5tail;t1 9t5.nal;y & text "u/&+4 ,9 ,proce$+s ( ! ,,hlt- ,,naacl #bjjc "w%op on ,text m1n+ "4 ,dagan1 ,i41 ,glickman1 ,o41 `& ,magn9i1 ;,b4 "<#bjje1 ,april">4 ,! pascal recognis+ textual 5tail;t *all5ge4 ,9 ,ma*9e ,le>n+ ,*all5ges ,"w%op "4 ,spr+}1 ,b}l91 ,heidelb}g4 ,fyodorov1 ;,y41 ,w9t}1 ;,y41 `& ,fr.ez1 ;,n4 "<#bjjj">4 ,a natural logic 9f};e sy/em4 ,9 ,proce$+s ( ! #bnd ,"w%op on ,9f};e 9 ,computa;nal ,semantics "<,,ic,'o,s-#b">4 ,ham1 ;,j41 ,*oe1 ;,y4 ;,j41 ,p>k1 ;,k41 ,*oi1 ,i41 `& ,soh1 ;,h4 "<#bjbj">04 ,kornli & kor/s3 ,new b5*m>k datasets = kor1n natural language "u/&+4 >,xiv prepr9t >,xiv3#bjjd4jcbhi4 ,j91 ;,d41 ,j91 ;,z41 ,zh|1 ;,j4 ;,t41 `& ,szolovits1 ;,p4 "<#bjbj1 ,april">4 ,is b}t r1lly robu/ a /r;g basel9e = natural language attack on text classifica;n& 5tail;t4 ,9 ,proce$+s ( ! ,,aaai 3f};e on >tificial 9tellig;e "<,vol4 #cd1 ,no4 #je1 pp4 #hjah-hjbe">4 -----------------------------#fe 0,khot1 ;,t41 ,sabh>wal1 ,a41 `& ,cl>k1 ;,p4 "<#bjah">4 ,scitail3 ,a textual 5tail;t dataset f sci;e "q answ}+4 ,9 ,?irty-,second ,,aaai ,3f};e on ,>tificial ,9tellig;e4 ,lee1 ;,s41 ,jang1 ;,h41 ,baik1 ;,y41 ,p>k1 ;,s41 `& ,%91 ;,h4 "<#bjbj">4 ,kr-b}t3 ,a small-scale kor1n-specific language model4 >,xiv prepr9t >,xiv3#bjjh4jcigi4 ,mac,c>tney1 ;,b41 `& ,mann+1 ;,c4 ;,d4 "<#bjji1 ,janu>y">4 ,an ext5d$ model ( natural logic4 ,9 ,proce$+s ( ! ei4 b#fd ;<5`uegj) #acg ,nie1 ;,y41 ,williams1 ,a41 ,d9an1 ;,e41 ,bansal1 ;,m41 ,we/on1 ;,j41 `& ,kiela1 ;,d4 "<#bjai">4 ,adv}s>ial ,,nli3 ,a new b5*m>k = natural language "u/&+4 >,xiv prepr9t >,xiv3#aiaj4adeii4 ,nie1 ;,y41 ,williams1 ,a41 ,d9an1 ;,e41 ,bansal1 ;,m41 ,we/on1 ;,j41 `& ,kiela1 ;,d4 "<#bjbj">4 ,adv}s>ial ,,nli3 ,a ,new ,b5*m>k = ,natural ,language ,"u/&+1 ,,acl #bjbj4 ,p>k1 ;,s41 ,moon1 ;,j41 ,kim1 ;,s41 ,*o1 ;,w4 ,i41 ,han1 ;,j41 ,p>k1 ;,j41 444 `& ,*o1 ;,k4 "<#bjba">4 ,klue3 ,kor1n language "u/&+ evalua;n4 >,xiv prepr9t >,xiv3#baje4jifhj4 ,szeg$y1 ;,c41 ,z>emba1 ;,w41 ,sutsk"e1 ,i41 ,bruna1 ;,j41 ,}han1 ;,d41 ,gdfell{1 ,i41 `& ,f}gus1 ;,r4 "<#bjac">4 ,9trigu+ prop}ties ( neural net"ws4 >,xiv prepr9t >,xiv3#acab4faii4 ,wang1 ,a41 ,pruksa*atkun1 ;,y41 ,nangia1 ;,n41 ,s+h1 ,a41 ,mi*ael1 ;,j41 ,hill1 ;,f41444 `& ,b{man1 ;,s4 "<#bjai">4 ,sup}glue3 ,a /icki} b5*m>k = g5}al-purpose language "u/&+ sy/ems4 ,adv.es 9 neural 9=ma;n process+ sy/ems1 #cb ,wang1 ,a41 ,s+h1 ,a41 ,mi*ael1 ;,j41 ,hill1 ;,f41 ,levy1 ,o41 `& ,b{man1 ;,s4 ;,r4 "<#bjah">4 ,,glue3 ,a multi-task b5*m>k & analysis plat=m = natural language "u/&+4 >,xiv prepr9t >,xiv"1#ahjd4jgdfa4 -----------------------------#ff 0,williams1 ,a41 ,nangia1 ;,n41 `& ,b{man1 ;,s4 ;,r4 "<#bjag">4 ,a broad-cov}age *all5ge corpus = s5t;e "u/&+ "? 9f};e4 >,xiv prepr9t >,xiv3#agjd4jedbf4 ,zhang1 ;,w4 ;,e41 ,%5g1 ;,q4 ;,z41 ,alhazmi1 ,a41 `& ,li1 ;,c4 "<#bjbj">4 ,adv}s>ial attacks on deep-le>n+ models 9 b#fe ;<5`uegj) #aci natural language process+3 ,a survey4 ,,acm ,transac;ns on ,9tellig5t ,sy/ems & ,te*nology "<,,ti/">" #aa"<#c">" #a-da4 -----------------------------#fg "8~m"x01 #bjbb c* e1em7;o j5w ~g,? *`m eo2 `m;ma .o;o5 =gggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg= #bjbb c* e1em7;o j5w ~g,? eo2 *`m `m;ma .o;o5 =777777777777777777777777777777= #a4 `r+ #a4a4 ~( `v.nw ex.? ~( `v.n ,8#bjbb c* e1em7;o j5w ~g,? eo2 *`m0'n,scz `v3"*j3 ,)jr7 *`m8'0,nie et ;al4 #bjbj,0"! `o~3{"u .?ir.? l"/n `o~3j3 .<*s;m"( inohs ,nh{"! `m;majcz _s! exd+"u j3i4 ,8jvoh{jrfs0'q .m,?."! jv1+7j<: .?ir.? l"/"! `m;maj`u .asb."u j<:`{5 egeran ekcz $,t! ,r7,}jiu"x j<: "<~n1`v i"z irib! crcu0iu"x euin1! ,xo5 8'0fool+,0{"u,,s ,r"ug inohs ,nh{! e3i{cz _so .m+j3 ex.?oi4 #fg ~m"x #ada #a4b4 .?ir.? l"/ `r`v1 .?ir.? l"/ e1em7;ocz #f`rw weojv+7.? ;m"(~7,oa 8'0num}ical`&quant1 ref};e1 /&>d1 lexical1 tricky1 r1son+,0! o+7j<: j5w ~g,?iy3 .?ir.? l"/n `o~3j3 .<*s eg.7 inohs ,nh{oi 8'0,nie et ;al4 #bjbj,04 j5w ~g,?o"<3 .ms.q irl7 eg.7 8'i5jv,0v $,t eg.7n irjr i& $3w `v3`/"! ;<5`v `s.o'w .}iun `z`sj<: ;m"(jcz .asboi4 j5w 8'05tail;t,0" .m7"ob 8'0neutral,0" eu,g 8'03tradic;n,0w ,n $.o .m7 s,i) `}mn ,xjcz.o"! ;m"(j<: "<~n1! ~m;7_/ c1,. i{7w ,m;o.? .}~u" ~3ws_/ %ws_/.sb,x_/~m.}s i{7w c("o.? .}~u" `meg~*jv3_/.r.}"| i{7w a#fh ~m"x #adc h=l.? .}~u" q`v`v3`/" .a$wiu ;m"(`v $8z egera.? .}~u"! duj5j3i4 8'#c,0 ,ma,u ~"u imr,.x{"u .az ju,m$ o/s/`u" .3.3j3 e&`|n ~3,.a~3,.a ~o;ocz ~o2o `{i=<3w euiz `?.}! j3 ~)n ,,o'scrcz i{'ji4 i4 $,t eg.7"1 irl7 eg.7`v j5w `v3`/"! o"mcz eg.7{"u .?ir.? l"/w :aj1! jcz eg.7oi4 8'#d,0 ,ma,u ~"u imr,.xncz .az ju,m$ o/i4 "<4 "<~n1"1 irl7 eg.7`v $,t eg.7 $3w j5w `v3`/oi4 j5w" .m7"ob" eu,g .m7 j3 $.o"u ,)hraiy3i4 <"rcz irl7 eg.7 8'#c,0`v $,t eg.7 8'#d,0 $,t eg.7 $3w j5w `v3`/oi4 8'#e,0 j5w8'0,e,0 e4 ,te}"1 .asb.$ "<~n1! ,)hraj3 o%n irj3 ,te}oi4 -----------------------------#fi 8'#f,0 ,8,ma,u ~"u imr,.x{"u .az ju,m$ o/s/i0'cz e}.n$ irl7 eg.7n .sb,xiys *`|iye{"u irl7 eg.7o ;<5oe* $,t eg.7iu ~3i{,o ;<5oi4 ~4 j5w `v3`/"1 irl7 eg.7`v $,t eg.7 $3w weojv+7.? `v3`/oi4 ~( `v.nn,scz c("oja.?q8'0logical,0 `v3`/,~ge3 7,0"1 `o,m eo2 ,s,mn irj3 ;m"(" ,m'.d8'd+.g,0"1 .sb,x" ~m.}" q`v`v3`/" ~o`+`{b`v ;yl7`{b ;m"( h4 0lexical8'sjmr,0"1 i=ws" b#fi ~m"x #adg ~3wsn irj3 sjmr .}~u d4 0tricky8',xo5,m,0"1 e1.7c3 8'0~wplay,0" `meg ~*jv3 8'0syntactic trans=ma;n,0" .r.}"|8'0reord}+,0_/egeran,s .a$ wiu ;m"(`v $8z )s .)">a ;m"( j4 0r1son+ `& facts8';m"( eo2 l,o1,0"1 ,nl7n irj3 y~m .o,oa ,iucz ;m$ l,o1"u~mhs ;m"( #b4 .asb .t;< #b4a `m;ma .t;< `m;n.?q lsb cr+7z i<{5 ,n $.o"u `m,}iy3i4 ;s',.r" .?ir.? j5w `v3`/ ~g,? .o;o5! ,m"obj3i4 .o;o5 ,m"obw cr+7z ~g,? irl7! ,).}j<: ~g,? ~7~sb"(! ,m"obj`u euin1 ja,{b eo2 d}$ `|`v"! `s5.{7j`u `r,)! mrj3 ~7~sb"(! ,m"objcz _soi4 i&,.r" .?ir.? j5w `v3`/ e1em7;o"! `m;maj3i4 `m;maw i3`/cz i<{5`v $8i4 e).s `=`riy3 `ma"ob`masp3 ,qeg e1em7;o #bjba 8'#bjbj c* ,r7l3iy3 ,qeg `ol #gbi1bhj`),0n,s ~g,? irl7! ,).}j3i4 `{i<{5 .?ir.? j5w `v3`/ ,r7,}! mrj3 $,t iu;& eo2 ,te} .}~u"! ~m;7 d<aj3 .?ir.? .<*s;m"( l"/"! e3i{cz :aj1! ~m:j3i4 "7j3 .7"{w e1em7;on,s ~ui .?ir.?q l"/"! .n.aj3i4 -----------------------------#gb 82`{"o5#b;0 .?ir.? l"/ ,r7,} `=.} =gggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg= 82,)jr7 5 irl7 eg.7 ;m;&"1 ,qeg e1em7;o #bjban,s ,)jr7 5 irl7 eg.7 ;m;&;0 ~3o 82$,t eg.7 ,r7,}"1 irl7 eg.7! ~h7{"u $,t eg.7 ,r7,} eo2 0label4 ~m;d1 ,lexical1 ,tricky1 ,r1son+ `& ,facts,0;0 0,bottom-up"1 .o;o5 sb'o .?ir.? l"/ ,r7,} 3o ,r7,}iy3 .?ir.? l"/ ~g,? 3o ~g,? inohs"u~mhs ;m"( ~7,oa ;m;& 0,top-d{n"1 #f`rw ;m"( ~7,oan `z`sj3 .o;o5 ,r7,} 3o .o;o5n `o~3j3 .?ir.? l"/ ,r7,} 3o euin10fool+4 ,oiu 82~|iuw .o;o5 sb'o .?ir.? l"/"! ,r7,)j3 0,,anil 8'0,nie et ;al4 #bjbj,0 0|o ,bottom-up ,approa*;0 7 0,me*anical ,turk4w .asb.i!o ~|iuw .o;o5 sb'o 0,bottom-up4 ~7,oa{"u ,r7,}j3 .?ir.? l"/"! ~g,?j<: ;= #f`rw ;m"( ~7,oao ~o.m7 o/`n l+7iys/{5! ljm ~g,?j54 820,,anli4 ;m"( ~7,oan `z`sj3 .o;o5! h=j3 ~( `v.nw ,r7,} `=.} 3o 0,top-d{n ,approa*;0 7 0,nie et ;al4 8'#bjbj,0n,s ;m;&j3 #f`rw ;m"( ~7,oa b#gb ~m"x #aec 8'0,num}ical `& ,quant1 ,ref};e `& ,"ns1 ,/&>d1 ,lexical1 ,tricky1 ,r1son+ `& ,facts,0 .m7 j3 l"/i7 #b-c`rw ;m"( ~7,oa! l+7j<: l"/"! ,r7,}jiu"x .o;o5 .n.a4 =777777777777777777777777777777= 82`{"o5#d;0 .?ir.? l"/ ,r7,} /,o =gggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg= egera"1 `ma"ob`}.m~ae&`v3z #aiha c* ,o1,oj3 `{5;?"o `u~g #ah`o ~1`&.ul `|`v"! ;y`z #dj c* e3n ~u`u,s8'8`}.m `{5;?"o ,q" j3i4 #2 egera .}~u"! ;yirj3 jv1+7j3i4 8'#aj,0 82i5jv;0 <,~d,0 .?+7"1 .sb,x 82$,t #b i3`/;0 s5e7 c,0 eu,g `v3`/ - ir"ob ow `v3`/" l7~u ~3w `v3`/" `v3`/~3ws .m7 :aw`v3`/" >7"ob ~&$c{7 `v3`/ b#gc ~m"x #aeg i,0 .m7"ob - j5w `v3`/ eo2 eu,g `v3`/$ ,}"obj.o <30cz `}m #2 ,n`/ .o,oa ,o$3 ;m"(" `=$3 ;m"(" >7.? ;m"(" o1~3 l7,oa <"rcz l"/~| /,ooi4 #a4 %ws 8'#ab,0 82i5jv;0 .oc3 #ep1 o`ojg jc`{5%7hm. *`mp3z ~oajoh{ n3hshnqe)h{w /l7 `osb$;o"u #c.u #ijjj?--#e.u#bjjj?p3! .n,ojr/i4 ems'~ui 0,,bts4w q`o$ ;y`u.uqini ,o1.n ;-$d"z ,o1.? ,}.7-2! `m$j`u o/icz .s5o $7.s5oi4 82$,t;0 0,,bts4w q`o$ ;y`u.uqini ,o1.n ,o1.?iu ;-$d"z ,}.7 $iu-2"! i1"o`u o/icz .s5o $7.s5oi4 82j5w;0 0,e4 #b4 ~3ws 8'#ac,0 82i5jv;0 ,q.= fu"uc~ jcz juhn1 sb`/$ ~oire* efnho7n ;u.s5! ek;p "7jvl,0 8'#ad,0 82i5jv;0 <&"s 0,,wcif4cz {5d0'"! .n.}jr #a jy ,ml7."u 0,k-,,pop4 jry.q;&w ,)`m.a{"u s,g ~*`}iu l+7iys/i4 8'#ae,0 82i5jv;0 oh1"o<3 "n,{hu"<7 l1~hu"nfmueu" ~nh{c5 ,oai7 he"qi{" j3.},oa.ob jvco" ,i?$1~o .)eg.s5 i?q`v3 i{7n,s ,oal imr ,q,n`/ .nj% fi{"u `|.nje* #cj0p j1qo .?+7iy3i4 j*ir~rajv.s5 ;-a"2`|.n,o,{hn5! `m;majr ,m,m"+ i{7 `}}~mi5! .&o`u" em,q`u ,ma~a,o,tw ;<5:"! .nj3jr <3.)j3 `v3`v7 jv3`}! .u,}j1 ~7;o5oi4 .}~mcz j>7jm ,o1.{7h{a"/ g} ,o1.?`v ,qlsbo c=;( `}.n"2ljyn eo;ocz }j>7 i{7! ;-.=jb.?{"u `u":jr-2 ~sb"2.niu .}~o"! `s5huj`o"u jr/i4 82$,t;0 ~sb"2.niu .}~ocz j>7jm ,o1.{7h{a"/ g} ,o1.?`v ,qlsbo c=;( `}.n"2ljyn eo;ocz }j>7 i{7o ;-.=jb.?{"u `u":iy1-2 _soi4 82j5w;0 0,e4 #f4 .m.n-c(d}`m.u 8'#ai,0 ;u.s5w mr;o$ i"z `}m 82i5jv;0 `v;),ocz .oc3 #bdo1 `v;)"reo<3,n3h{"t,{mrh{ i3.o fdnn,s e7 .{7$"u os.q _s{"u ~g,?jr/i4 -----------------------------#gi #b,0 ~xp3 7 irl7 i5jvn .msc ex.?s$ sb'! `}m $,t eg.7n,scz egeral7 /;{aj1 ,m o/cz eg.7 +,u"! ~xp3j<: .n,oj3i4 8'#bg,0 82i5jv;0 o e,{f{cz nh3u1 l1`%3 ,n;? ,o1js5! .qjr7j3 `|`v #bj jy ~3~x ,n;? jmniu ;u`o :`v j+%1 #id0p ol7! %.oj`u ccu,s5% en5~{"nqw `m.u ~*jv$ .)j: o1sc.o <30cz _so `v3;<1! h=jr jvaqjr/i4 h{ajo nh3u1n #c,o$3 ol7 i5$iu ccu,s5%$ cx`sc en5~{"nqw imrh!"o5 j*l7o sb's nh3u1! o+7jr l1`%3"2,n;?j1 `}m j3 i1 ol7 l+7o $c{7j3 .7.s5o o/i4 82$,t;0 nh3u1z o e,{f{"! j3 i1 ol7 l+7 $c{7j`n e3izi4 82j5w;0 0,e4 #c,0 egera.? .}~u m,) 7 l.).? .}~uv egera.? .}~u$ l7;m7j1 ,ir" egera.? .}~u"! m,)j3i4 8'#bh,0 82i5jv;0 mj3 ;n"% `+eqi!z oc1 u.) #e,o 8'j*.o,o$3,0,`n ;&~1jr u.) #h,o,`n `o5du`=j7n iu;7jm .}~m ~7;o5n ,i"< ,8,r7jv1 ,x `s"oim`o0'"uw .)jv3 ,o e*eo1j3 `s5hu"! `s;: i<{5i1 #fo1 ojm iui?l3fr5do7.7" `v7e}`maeq;n%a ,n3hs i{7 lsb.7iu ;m$"u .r`r.7 j1 `/jyaoi4 j%.7`o$3 i=<3 `=lcz .=jb.?q ,o,t.s5`s5! ,o1,ojr - `v7e}`u1d{*,{b.7 `{e&e7 ~u,m `=lv h,? q.u .3io `+;n`=l - `v7e}`maeq;n%a,n3hs ;<7eg $"o5ea a#hj ~m"x #aga `=l" ,o1cr ~ia ,r3io7 `=l" <3crin,{f{ `r,) `=l - iui?l3 fr5do7.7 ,r7hr*eu' &h"o ~u,m `=l" inf{ ,m,) `=l - ,o"ob.x`m.7 $ j3i4 ,i"<,s ,o1.n ,n`/n,scz l,o1o1.o eu"{c egera .}~u l7n,s l,o1 :~m"! d3i3j1 ,m sb'cz .}~ucz .m7"ob{"u ;s"oj3i4 8'#ca,0 82i5jv;0 i=`ma.n$7z h3":a.? .usbo $c{7j3 .)`o"u lsbw .7.s5! `{airjvjcz in .m":ajr/i4 :`on isjr ;<~|jviy3 ~=j}$7`v ft"s $7d3 ,q.ndm5 i{7 `u~m$$;o .ndm5`v ,t"m,* efnho7 iuob i{7 ,o.7! ,)iujcz ;u`:a;< .)">a! .o,xje: ,moa,} jvairn ;-er.qjr/i4-2 -----------------------------#ha 82$,t;0 i=`ma.n$7w ~=j}$7`v ft"s$7d3 ,q.ndm5z ;-er.qiys/i4-2 82j5w;0 0,n4 3o ,o1.n ,n`/n,s i=`ma.n$7w ~=j}$7`v ft"s$7d3 ,q.ndm5o er.qiys/is"7 `r_xxl _xxxl +ajcz `se* c#hj ~m"x #agc eu"zi4 ri!iu o/cz i=cnn,s c5,}w ,}`o" :,}w ,}`o i!e?oe: ,isi{czin `+%a.?{"u .u0`n/c{c>0e: 8.s") _xxl jc o/cz _se3{"uiu ;m7~gj3in vr i=cn"! ,,{"n`o"u e3i{c{c>0`u hu"ujr/i4 #c4c ;m"( .?+7 p3;oa 99 ;m"( .?+7 ,o i<{5w p3;oai!! ,i"zi4 #a,0 0num}ical `& quant8',mv >7,0 7 irl7 eg.7n,s ,m'.7j3 l*o .sb,mivr/i4 82$,t;0 .oc3 #dp1`v #ep1n ;8;= #aejj:`)-2o .sb,miys/i4 82;m"(;0 0num}ical`&quant1 r1son+`&fact 82j5w;0 0,e4 8'#ce,0 82i5jv;0 on irjr .rd3~mcz oc1 8`s5;<1 ;{ao j7,u"! #hb ~m"x #age jr/ijis"d1 lexical4 82j5w;0 0,e4 #b,0 0ref};e `& "n8'.o,ov o"{5,0 7 l7ju;<5.ujcz o1~3e}l" `u%e}l jxz 8'ir,0e}l $3w `v3`/"! ,xo5 8'0fool+,0 8'#cg,0 82i5jv;0 `=dun .o1"q `{cz 8c<{"o" `}~oi! ,iregn c$1 ,mc o/`n/,{bco,$80"d4 82j5w;0 0,c4 8'#ch,0 82i5jv;0 #e`r irjaz `}jwirja`+8'+7q,0" ,}`%3`v3 irja`+8',mp3,0" *,nirja`+ 8'q;),0" j3>7irja`+8'<3l3,0" j3`may`masirja`+8'+7q,0i4 #bjab c*~mhs ,o.aj3 ,8l5,}i{"o5 f!"r,{0'cz ;-`+%a :`)o ~m.xj3 .o:aw .m7ja,r7-2n`n irja,r7o en3hu$ ivr ja,{b! .op3jcz l5,}.).7o o/ie* i"z l"<5i!~ui $5:5 mrjs5n cu;&iy1 $c{7,}o is cu4i`u ~uiujr/i4 o"z~ ,8ca`v3.mw d*j>7,}0'o $7jie* ,o1.n mrjs5n irjr .1 <1`u o/{5niu ~&`mj`u ;-~(q-2o ;sj3 mrjs5! ;ma,ujcz `}j>7o $7jicz ,te}oi4 82$,t;0 ;-ca`v3.mw d*j>7,}o $7j3 l"<5-2z ,o1.n"u ;-.,q-2o s,i) mr`on ;sjr o/cz.o <1.o eu'j3i4 82;m"(;0 0ref}5ce`&"ns1 /&>d4 82j5w;0 0,c4 #c,0 0/&>d8'd+.g,0 7 q`v.? c("o `v3`/"! ,xo5 8'0fool+,0 8'#dj,0 82i5jv;0 ;}vir `maeq;}p3 `n,od3ncz #ajo1 ,8!v7"o {5.mg.) :a.mjr7{"u b#hc ~m"x #agi ;<5~*! i7j3 #ej ir $.7w ,i1obcoi0'"7n ;o: ,m5.q 0,a8'#ed,0,,ow ,i1o"<`u .,q! ,u`rj3 ;}p3qz i7,o $jr.i!o l`u j*.7n,s ;-#aai~ui ~*jul"! e).s ;d1 tricky4 82j5w;0 0,c4 8'#da,0 82i5jv;0 ucz #bjbb c*,$.o ;m.qiycz o lsbz `ma~o #bce?p3" ,o~o #bae?p3 i{7 ;= #dej?p3o hmobiy3i4 `).ulcz ;-y~m d}$mrp3jyw ,o5w"! `s;: 8'.m,0j*ireodu.u,)o ,).}-2ivr/i4 82$,t;0 ;-j*ireodu.u,)o y~m d}$mrp3jy"! ,o5wjr/i4-2 82;m"(;0 0/&>d4 82j5w;0 0,c4 8'#db,0 82i5jv;0 j.}mcz ;-~(qw j%ir.)jv"! jrfo7j3 j:b~a~s5-2`v irjv"u ,o$3! ~te: `};<1w ,ml"! iuv/.oe3 ,`{8cr .oa.sb irjv"! j3 coacno5 ,8`uju0'cz .m7`ma{"u iudoj3 l7hri4 ,{7.rj* j}l.};ra *`mp3 *`mmrp3z j%ir.)jv jrfo7 ~7.o;ra{"u ,n$.o .o;o5! ,`x .of:> j3i`u $7.ujr/i4 82$,t;0 ;-j.}mcz j%ir.)jv"! jrfo7jr/i4-2 82;m"(;0 0ref}5ce`&"n1 tricky4 82j5w;0 0,c4 7 ~m.} `v3`/"! ,xo58'0fool+,0 8'#dc,0 82i5jv;0 o .u;ocz `u`ma{"u iu1d1 lexical4 82j5w;0 0,c4 7 ~o`+ `v3`/"! ,xo58'0fool+,0 8'#de,0 82i5jv;0 v3iu`g `=i=`v3n,scz jv1.)~x`v jv1`v7s" jr;u ,r1"si{" jr;u i($,{" jr;u`ma,m" .)~x.7" .)~x .td* i{7 i<>7j3 .ndm5! `macry ~7`o8'jr.u"%,0" v3iu;qjv3`} j:bi=.ujb8'jr.u"%,0-2oi4 82$,t;0 `=i=`v3n ;<5$j3 sb;n .m7 ;-jr.u"%"! d3erjcz sb;n~ui .)~x! d3erjcz sb;n$ is e30i4-2 82;m"(;0 0num}ical`&quant1 /&>d1 r1son+`&facts4 82j5w;0 0,c4 a#he ~m"x #ahc 8'#df,0 82i5jv;0 .}~mcz r;u `q`{b.rc3.op3`{5 /l3! #i.u #gjjj?p38';-#b;< ;m`} #g.u #fjjj?p3 5 .o~7.}~m ~gi5`{5 #b.u #ajjj?p3-2,0{"u .bd4 82j5w;0 0,c4 #c,0 0lexical8'sjmr,0 7 i=ws jxz ~3ws `v3`/ $3w sjmr"! ,m.}j<: ,xo58'0fool+,0 -----------------------------#hf 8'#dg,0 82i5jv;0 #bjbj ,{du;{,s& "7z .oc3jr #d~g`o #beb e3irn,s #aed e3ir"u" 0,,oled4 d3er">7z #aaa e3irn,s #fb e3ir"u o1.njo $5,ujr/`u d3er">7 `:a;a`v #h ir jra,o5`v.n"! ~1d+jr/i4 `v7.m,ocz .oc3i1 #bao1 ;-`macr ;y;u"u #bjde c*,$.o h3,u.m7"ob ncs.o ."obiu,o"! e3i!`n/i-2cz `v7.mj} 0,,ai4-`{"qc%io1w exd+"! .n,oj`u .)":a~meg! #ajj0p ,q.r,r7 ncs.o"u .)jv3jcz #a;< "ui{erb! ~1d+j3 ~ o/i4 82$,t;0 ;-`macr ;y;uw h3,u.m7"ob ncs.o ."obiu,ocz `v7.moi4-2 82;m"(;0 0lexical1 tricky4 82j5w;0 0,c4 8'#ec,0 82i5jv;0 <4,s ~a.o%3" ;yi=,? 7z /l3o #bah0mm"u $.7 e30`u" ;)<3 #bab0mm" ;-7z 7z 7z ;-" m"o .m7#c,ir ,r7o1 dho .q,. .reo/s/czin0"d1 r1son+`&facts4 82j5w;0 0,c4 #c4d ,te} .a,} p3;oa 99 ,te} .a,} ,o i<{5w p3;oai!! ,i"zi4 #a,0 v3.)j3 eg.7 j}hr"u `o,& -----------------------------#hi 7 v3.)j3 eg.7 j}hr$ d1 lexical 82j5w;0 0,c 82,te};0 ,q;} ;s'c1 ;y`u #bd e3e}o i=,o .sb,xjcz ~"<5n .sb,x. dx.m"u q.{7 ,s~s$ i7j3 ~u5;t .}`o ,no1 jr7ln c,)i4 82$,t;0 ,u~o,o5"o$ ;y`z j3 i1$3 `{b.q.?{"u `r,)iy`u o/cz .s5e3 jriu weo$ sb'cz _so d1 lexical4 82j5w;0 0,c4 82,te};0 `{b.q.?{"u `r,)iycz _so iabil;y4 ,9 ,proce$+s ( ! ,,pascal ,"w%op on ,le>n+ ,me?ods = ,text ,"u/&+ & ,m9+4 ,gr5oble1 ,fr.e4 ,glickman1 ,o4 #bjjf4 ,appli$ ,textual ,5tail;t4 ,ph4,d4 ,!sis4 ,b>,ilan ,univ}s;y4 ,yix9 ,nie1 ,ad9a ,williams1 ,emily1 ,d9an1 ,mohit ,bansal1 #ia ;<5`u egj) #aie ,jason ,we/on1 ,d|we ,kiela"<#bjbj">1 ,adv}s>ial ,,nli3 ,a ,new ,b5*m>k = ,natural ,language ,"u/&+1 ,,acl #bjbj4 ,nie1 ;,y41 ,williams1 ,a41 ,d9an1 ;,e41 ,bansal1 ;,m41 ,we/on1 ;,j41 `& ,kiela1 ;,d4 "<#bjbj">4 ,adv}s>ial ,,nli3 ,a new b5*m>k = natural language "u/&+4,9 ,proce$+s ( ! #ehth ,annual ,meet+ ( ! ,associa;n = ,computa;nal ,l+ui/ics1 pages #dhhe,-dija4 ,j91 ;,d41 ,j91 ;,z41 ,zh|1 ;,,,j4 ;t41 `&,' ,szolovits1 ;,p4 "<#bjbj">4 ,is ,,b}t r1lly robu/8 ,a /r;g basel9e = natural language attack on text classifica;n & 5tail;t4 ,9 ,proce$+s ( ! ,,aaai 3f};e on >tificial 9tellig;e1 #cd"<#je">1 pages #hjah-hjbe4 =gggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg= "8`ojya"2*`m01 `ma"ob`masp3 $7eo} )s.}~u`v.7 `ma"ob`masp3 %jw.} ja/*`ml `ma"ob`masp3 oeq.m *`mp3 `ma"ob`masp3 ~aeoz *`mp3 `ma"ob`masp3 .}}z *`mp3 "8lsb ;<5:.01 ;rao5 *`mp3 `o5o1jv3 8',},q:.irja`+,0 `=i= *`mp3 $7<"{5 8';m7c5irja`+,0 `o5hrm8'~ml3irja`+,0 ~a.qju8',s&irja`+,0 ~aj*<8'`u":irja`+,0 ,=l7j)8'`u":irja`+,0 ,=},ma8'.m,0c"<.o,oa.}~u oiu`o18'`u":irja`+,0 o.oz8'`u":irja`+,0 .7j<*8'~ml3y`masirja`+,0 .},!<8',},q:.irja`+,0 .}*.m8'j=oairja`+,0 .u`};<38'.m,0c"<.o,oa.}~u ;y%3.o8'qjirja`+,0 d3`p3 .}~u #aig *`m ~u.up3 `o5iuj* 8'`u":irja`+,0 j=,{7j/8'`u":irja`+,0 ,qg,sb8'`u":irja`+,0 o`%eq8'`u":irja`+,0 cu$7l38'`u":irja`+,0 jv7i=.q8'`u":irja`+,0 >7.q<8';m7c5irja`+,0 3333333333333333333333333333 ~1jr7q"1 `ma"ob`masp3.7 ~1jr7;s"1 `ma"ob`masp3 ,s&,o $7,s`m `{5c7jv"u #aed .)jv #jb-bffi-igge" .),= #jb-bffi-igbg q,vro1"1 #bjbc c* #ap1 #aio1 ~1jr7o1"1 #bjbc c* #ap1 #aio1 q,vr"1 ,},q0,,pod4 3333333333333333333333333333 99 o ;raz `ma"ob`masp3w +7:a~o"u ,mjr7j3 ,8#bjbb c* e1em7;o j5w ~g,? eo2 *`m0' lsbw `|`ve&! ~1$3j3 _sobcoi4 =777777777777777777777777777777=