=gggggggggggggggggggggggggg= = = = 333333333333333333333333 = = d],r7`+%a^7! eo;ocz$8 = = 333333333333333333333333 = = = = = = ^a%3,m8',mae]:.irja`+ = = `].nja^m,0 = = = = = = = = `ma$d],r7`+%a.qj[7p3 = = = =77777777777777777777777777= 0,,or#bjbd-#aj d],r7`+%a^7! eo;ocz$8 ^a%3,m8',mae]:.irja`+ `].nja^m,0 =gggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg= ^( *`mn,s .n,oj3 .];ra .n)oc w`*z *`m.qw `*jroe:" `ma$d],r7`+%a.qj[7p3w `=,oa ob.7`v i"! ,m o/,[bcoi4 =777777777777777777777777777777= `ma$d],r7`+%a.qj[7p3 #a ex;< ,'p3^( dno.o ^)ju .s5. dno.o ^)ju,g["u .?[5,' 0,i4 ,s"( """"""""""""" #a#e 0,,ii4 d],r7`+%a^7 """""""""""""""""""""""""" #e#g 0,,iii4 #bjai c* d],r7`+%a ^7 """""""" #i#aa #a4 `r+ """"""""""""""" #aa#ab #b4 ^7 """"""""""""""" #ac#bj #f4 ^g,? `\`v"1 ja,[b ;<5:%1n eo;q ]j>7 """"""""""""""" #af#bh 0,,iv4 #bjbc c* d],r7`+%a ^7 """"""" #ai#cg ex;< #c #a4 `r+ """"""""""""""" #ba#ch #b4 ^7! eo;o1,$8 o `!z d],r7`+%a^7 o `!n,s i"mcz ^7z ^78'0causal e6ect,00! weoj3i4 ^7z s,is0`n .]wiy1 ,m o/!,$8 o .o1egn ibj`o mrjr ^7! eo;ocz.o /"! i!s ,te]jr ^u`n/i4 ^a ^a 0,a4$ ^7z #cj e3 p3o j1 _soi4 ol7w c(w"! .]"oje*" ^7z i<[5 im l7jv7n,sw jr7i= ;7! ;m"(j`o mrj3 `v3`)z 8e3>a ^n i1": o/i4 ------------------------------#h #bjbc c* d],r7`+%a^a ^7! ;m.]j<:/i4 #bjai c* d],r7`+%a^7! ;m.]j<:/i4 #bjai c* d],r7 `+%a^7! ;m.]j<:/i4 ojge numb],0o ,]"obiy1 .]iu"u ;m7^gjo fs> j3icz .u`)o do1+ji4 ------------------------------#i 0,,iii4 #bjai c* d],r7`+%a^7 #a4 `r+ #b4 ^7 #f4 ^g,? `\`v"1 ja,[b ;<5:%1n eo;q ]j>7 #i 0,,iii4 #aa -----------------------------#aa 0,,iii4 #bjai c* d],r7`+%a^7 #a4 `r+ #bjai c* d],r7`+%a^7! .m"u i"ms/`u" ^a%3,m8'#bjbj,0cz ja,[b ;<5:%1n eo;q ]j>7! .m"u i"ms/i4 ojaj3i4 #b4 ^aj3i4 #bjai c* d],r7`+%a^a #ah4d0p "! ;<.ojr/i4 ,teg.uln,scz [7ib."u `m^gj`u" [7ib.$ $a ,n^m ^g>w $7.v"! ,m$7jcz in hmobj3 p1^\ `+%a^o .o;&`v ja,[b ,o$3! `o.rjiu"x j<:/i4 #a1fci e]w #bjai c* #ap1^mhs #ajp1,$.o p1^\ `+%a^o .o;&ra`v ja,[b ,o$3! .ulj3 p1$3 drct ."+8'0mon?ly panel data,0$ ,m.obiy3 ,n5oi4 c#ab 0,,iii4 #c4 #ag -----------------------------#ac #d4 ^g,? ^7^sb ^*.=o5 y8'#bjbj,0v ^a%3,m8'#bjbj,0cz ,m.obiy3 p1$3 drct ."+n o.m7;<^g^sb 8'0di6];e-in-di6];es,0! .?+7j<: ^7! ;m.]j<:/i4 o.m7;<^g^sbz `].nja! duj5j3 ljy`vja ^g>n,s q`v.? ]j>7! ^g,?jcz in ct"o l+7iycz ^7^sboi4 ^x,mw .obi3! :"s ,o.s5n `t;:,s ^o`+jcz _s! `u1."u j3i4 ^*.=o5 y8'#bjbj,0v ^a%3,m8'#bjbj,0cz #bjai c* ^7o o/cz.o"! ;m.]j`u" `[ ;m.];o"! ^7["u jr,?j<:/i4 /"! i!s" #bjai c* #ep1 #cao1n ^7o o/cz.o"! ^g,?jcz ^7,oa["u ^7! ;m.]j<:/i4 a#ac 0,,iii4 #d4 #ai #e4 ^g,? `\`v"1 `+%a^o .o;&n eo;q ]j>7 ^*.=o5 y8'#bjbj,0cz #bjai c* d],r7`+%a^7! ^g,?jr/i4 "7d+ #b71cz `[ ;m.] `\`v"! +>aj3 _soi4 drct 0,a4cz euiz d],r7ja,[b $7.vn irj3 p1 `+%a^o .o;& j+`v"! ^u:.me:" drct 0,b4cz d],r7ja,[b $7.v"! #bg`r ,n^m ^g>"u ccms $a ^g>^\"u p1 `+%a^o .o;&n eo;q j+`v"! chcr3i4 8'#a,0\z .);n ^^\ ;u_/.m7_/`ui[7ja`+ .u1sbja":a q.] `v.]"1 8#j4jja #j4jja #j4jjj0 irja`+8'#b" #c" #d c*.n,0"1 8#j4jib #j4jfc #j4bcj0 ^7,=h=,qirja`+"1 8#j4jab #j4jaj #j4jcb0 lo^sirja`+"1 8#j4aaf #j4aee #j4jcb0 irjap38',?_/^al,0"1 8#j4jgi #j4jie #j4jjj0 `ui[7 ja":a^uv3`+%a8'ja.s5 zjr7.n" ixjajamr.n i[7,0"1 8#j4jhi #j4aef"9"9 9#j4bci0 `s5.]`u,o $7.v8';u"2.m7"2`ui[7 ja`+,0"1 8#j4jbh #j4jcd #j4jjj0 a#ad 0,,iii4 #e4 #ba .qja .g^o $7.v8'd*ob" irjap3 .g^o i[7,0"1 8#j4jcf #j4jah #j4jij0 egjr`+%a8'j3`!_/l3,m `+,o1 i[7,0"1 8#j4jdc"9"9"9 #j4jea"9"9"9 #j4jjj0 y`mas .`:a.[7 $7.v8'huoa" hud! i[7,0"1 8#j4bjh"9"9"9 #j4agg"9"9 #j4cgc"9"90 fs5d%hs .`:a.[7 $7.v8'fs5d%hs jv1+7c[7":a" pi[d["u,n,s i[7,0"1 8#j4acc"9"9 #j4jid #j4cae"9"90 .`:a.[7 q.[7 `v.]8'`=q.m7`rl" +>7^ujul i[7,0"1 8#j4eae"9"9"9 #j4ded"9"9"9 #j4iih"9"9"90 ;mrsb eo2 ;<7sb .g^o`v.] 8'`=emp3 ,ojs5 ir^o^3 i[7,0"1 8#j4jgb"9 #j4jgf"9 #j4jce0 .oaemc[7":a j>7l7 `+%a`v.] 8'.oaem*,m" pf[,+b i[7,0"1 8#j4jbb #j4jac #j4jhb0 `].n"2`]]$7.v8'd)i[" .rem,t`/" ^mi=l3 i[7,0"1 89#j4jjf 9#j4jaj #j4jjf0 y`mas$7.v8',r7jv1 y`mas i[7,0"1 8#j4jgd"9 #j4jad #j4dbf"9"90 fs5d%hs$7.v8'.]^u qhscn' ,u>7 `+%a i[7,0"1 8#j4jhe"9"9"9 #j4jhc"9"9"9 #j4jhg0 .=`+`+%a$7.v8',]`]" ^&`] $7.v i[7,0"1 8#j4jcb #j4jch 9#j4jjb0 qeg`+>7$7.v8':al_/;tja_/egja $7.v i[7,0"1 8#j4jhb"9"9 #j4ajb"9"9 #j4jjf0 $.],r7jv1$7.v8'+"o_/;],uc* `+%a" ,`u2,`uko i[7,0"1 8#j4bbe"9"9"9 #j4aia"9"9"9 #j4cdd"90 `)$7 eo2 w"+$7.v8'`[5*_/ ,r7jv1w"+ `+%a i[7,0"1 8#j4jca #j4jca 9#j4jjc0 [5a #b4f e3 p3 .[7$,ofocz _s["u chc/i4 ,ui[a +`)^\"u irl7."! ccms ^g,?j3 8'#b,0\`v 8'#c,0\! ^o`+je*" 8'#b,0\n,scz `o;u,r7jv1,m`[b.a #b4e e3 p3w .o;& .[7$ j+`v$ ;m.]iys/[c" 8'#c,0\w `o.g .m7mr,ui[a #fe0p oj $`mw `]m >a #c4b e3 p3w j+`v$ ;m.]iys/i4 .[a" ^"u `m^gj<: $a ^g>^\ ^cz .`:a.[7 q.[7 `v.]["u" ^a #j4eae e3 p3 .[7$j3 _s["u ^g,?iys/i4 ,iuj3" eo,& $7.v8'#j4bdi e3 p3,0" $.],r7jv1 $7.v8'#j4bbe e3 p3,0" y`mas .`:a.[7 $7.v8'#j4bjh e3 p3,0" [5a a#ae 0,,iii4 #e4 #be #j4b`9#j4be e3 p3 .]iuw `+%a^o .o;& .[7$ j+`v$ `v3;<1iys/`u" fs5d%hs .`:a.[7 $7.v8'#j4a #cc e3 p3,0" ,[du;[ $7.v8'#j4abg e3 p3,0 i[7n,siu %weoj3 j+`v$ jvaqiys/i4 .)^3.?["u ^7 ex.?w `+%a`v.]n irj3 `+%a^o .o;&! .m"u .[7$,ofq _s["u +>aiy3i4 drct 0,b4w 8'#b,0\`v 8'#c,0\z $a$a `o;u,r7jv1,m`[b. eo2 ^sb.] ;7! ^u:/i4 j3d*" `o.g .m7mr,ui[a #fe0p oj $`mn,scz y`mas $7.v8'#j4dbf e3 p3,0" y`mas .`:a.[7 $7.v8'#j4cgc e3 p3,0" fs5d%hs .`:a.[7 $7.v8'#j4cae e3 p3,0n irj3 .o;& .[7$$ imi["s.o.oe3" `o;u,r7jv1,m`[b. eo2 ^sb.] ;7 ex.?8'eo,& $7.v #j4bfh e3 p3" [57 #j4ajb e3 p3,0oc ja":a^uv3 ex.?8'`ui[7 ja":a ^uv3`+%a #j4aef e3 p3" egjr`+%a #j4jea e3 p3,0n irj3 .o;&o imi["s.:/i4 c#ae 0,,iii4 #e4 #bg -----------------------------#af #f4 ^g,? `\`v"1 ja,[b ;<5:%1n eo;q ]j>7 ^a%3,m8'#bjbj,0cz #bjai c* d],r7`+%a^7! ^g,?jr/i4 ;m.] `\`vcz "7d+ #c71n +>aiys o/i4 drct 0,a4cz .);n ^a #g4g0p duqh[ .[7$,of:/`u" :,]w `]m >a #aj4f0p duqh[ .[7$,of:/i8'drct 0,b,04 *"]^\"ucz #bj ir8'#ai`9#bi,n,0v #gj,n ol7n,s cu4z ja,[b ;<5:%1 .[7$ j+`v$ ;m.]iys/i8'drct 0,c,04 ja":a^\"ucz `u.u1 .obi3n,s8'drct 0,d,0" .o:a^\"ucz ;m7;]`p3! .nyj3 ^o,miu`p3n,s 8'drct 0,e,0 l7ir.?["u cu4z ja,[b ;<5:%1 .[7$ j+`v$ `v3;[aiys/i ,ui[a+`)^\"ucz `o;u,r7jv1,m`[b.c ;78'#e,00 """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 0,a4 .);n ,mj/."1 a#af 0,,iii4 #f4 #bi #j4jih"9"9"9 #j4jjh"9 8#j4jab"9"9"9 #j4jdh"9"9"9 #j4jea"9"9"90 0,b4 ,]^\ c5,]"1 #j4jgg"9"9"9 #j4jjf 8#j4jjc #j4jbf #j4jdb"9"9"90 :,]"1 #j4ajf"9"9"9 #j4jjh 8#j4jae"9"9"9 #j4jee"9"9"9 #j4jee"9"9"90 0,c4 *"]^\ #ai`9#bi,n"1 #j4aej"9"9"9 #j4jcj 8#j4jaj #j4jhe"9"9"9 #j4jdf"9"9"90 #cj`9#ci,n"1 #j4jhh"9"9"9 #j4jac"9 8#j4jag"9 #j4jdj"9 #j4jde"9"90 #dj`9#di,n"1 #j4jii"9"9"9 #j4jjd 8#j4jje #j4jed"9"9"9 #j4jde"9"9"90 #ej`9#ei,n"1 #j4jid"9"9"9 9#j4jjd 8#j4jac"9 #j4jbf #j4jhh"9"9"90 #fj`9#fi,n"1 #j4jaj 9#j4jjb 8#j4jcc 9#j4jjd 9#j4jaf0 -----------------------------#ag #gj,n ol7"1 #j4aba"9"9"9 #j4jja 8#j4jcj #j4jjf #j4aba"9"9"90 0,d4 ja":a^\ .m7.u1 oj"1 #j4jgf"9"9 9#j4jjc 8#j4jdc"9"9"9 #j4jah"9"9 #j4jec"90 `u.u1"1 #j4aba"9"9"9 #j4jaj 8#j4jje #j4jdb"9"9"9 #j4jgi"9"9"90 ir.u1"1 #j4jhg"9"9"9 #j4jjg 8#j4jji"9 #j4jeh"9"9"9 #j4jca"9"90 0,e4 .o:a^\ ,miu`p3"1 #j4jgg"9"9"9 #j4jaa 8#j4jjd #j4jde"9"9"9 #j4jdj"9"9"90 $7p3`p3"1 #j4acf"9"9"9 9#j4jbj 8#j4jag #j4jga"9"9 #j4jhe"9"90 ;m7;]`p3"1 #j4jah 9#j4jje 8#j4jje #j4jje 9#j4jjc0 .)"<`p3"1 #j4aeg"9"9"9 #j4jae 8#j4jah"9"9"9 #j4jef"9"9"9 #j4jhf"9"9"90 `]l7`p3"1 #j4abf"9"9"9 #j4jja a#ag 0,,iii4 #f4 #ca 8#j4jbc"9"9 #j4jeb"9"9"9 #j4jgh"9"9"90 0,f4 ,ui[a +`)^\ `o;u,r7jv1,m`[b"1 #j4jij"9"9"9 #j4jjd 8#j4jai"9"9"9 #j4jda"9"9"9 #j4jeb"9"9"90 ;7["u ,n^gjvj<: $a ^s5.mn irjr d],r7`+%a^aj3 drct 0,a4"! ^ue*" ^a #j4h0p duqh[ .[7$,of:/[c" fz ]j>7! eo;o.o <30z _s["u chc/i4 ocz #ce e3 p3w ^7 ex.?w ja,[bo $a$a #d4h0p duqh[v #e4a0p duqh[ .[7$j3 _s["u chc/`u" ja":a^uv3 ex.?w ja,[bz #a4b0p duqh["u l7ir.?["u ckz j+`v"! ^u:/i4 d+.gu;<"! `u":j1 ,ir" .oasbc[7":a`r^1`v ;mreo"2`+>7 ex.?w ja,[b ;<5: .[7$cz l,o1l7 i=o1j3 .]iu"u jr,?j1 ,m o/i4 drct 0,b`9;,h4cz irl7 .obi3^\"u `m^giy3 ;m.] `\`v"! ^u:.gi4 j],oa`+%a ;<5:cz .m"u #cj ir" `o.g .m7mr,ui[a #fe0p oj" eo;mrja .c:"! ig $`m" ;mrsb. .obi3n,s ^7 ex.?w ja,[bz .m"u #gj,n ol7`v `u.u1 .obi3n,s l7ir.?["u fz j+`v"! ^u:/i4 o"sj3 `\`vcz d],r7`+%a^7 ex.?["u ^7o f[icz l,o1o jvaqiy3i4 a#ah 0,,iii4 #f4 #ce -----------------------------#ai 0,,iv4 #bjbc c* d],r7`+%a^7 #a4 `r+ #b4 ^7! ^g,?j<:/i4 o"sj3 .sb`zz ^a ^7! ;m.]jcz in %"oj3 .7.s5o o/[c" i=,on .);n ^7e3! ^g,?j1 ,m o/icz i3.s5! $kczi4 ocz #bjai c* d],r7`+%a^7! ^g,?j3 ^*.=o5 y8'#bjbj,0oc ^a%3,m8'#bjbj,0v ir.u.?q h[a.o7oi4 i1"o d+j*je*" #bjbc c* lsbw j+`v"! ^g,?j3 ^a%3,m"2^am"<58'#bjd,0z #bjai c* lsbw j+`v"! ^g,?j3 ^*.=o5 y8'#bjbj,0c ^a%3,m8'#bjbj,0n ^ojr ^g,? `\`vw cr.? hi7,]8'09t]nal valid;y,0z cu4.oe3 y.? hi7,]8'0ext]nal valid;y,0cz cki`u d]$j1 ,m o/i4 a#ba 0,,iv4 #a4 #ci #b4 ^a #if1gjj e]os/[e:" `ma$.7ja`[5 .m7^x,mj/.c ,ui[a +`)! ;m7.xj.o eu'j3 #bb1gjj e]! .nyj3 >a #gd1jjj e]o ;y.=.?["u ,)^1 irl7o iys/i4 `m;n.? ,)^1 `v.]z "7d+ #d71n +>aiys o/i4 ,q;]. .m7 `o;u,r7jv1,m`[b.7! ^g,?jcz in jv1+7iy3 .obi3z ;m;s5! h=jr ^a #bh4j0p q #d1ajg e]o [7ibj<:/i4 ;m;s5,)^1.7["u jr,?j1 ,m o/! _soi4 ,i"<,s im .obi3 $3 jr7i=" ,r7$a" hriu i[7! ^o`+je* ^7! `v3;[aj1 ,m o/i4 #e4 ^g,? `\`v "7d+ #f71z ;m;s5,)^1.7! +>aj3i4 8'#a,0\z ;m;s5,)^1.7! weoj3i4 -----------------------------#be "7d+ #f71 #bjbc c* d],r7`+%a^7 =gggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg= =="1 8'#a,0 ;m;s5,)^1 8'#b,0 ;m;s5h1"7 `[5ra" .<*"u`[,0"1 #ba4fi #bj4gj #j4jii"9"9 `[7.].? l7ju,]8'#c`9#ba.s5,0"1 #ag4dj #ag4je #j4ceb"9"9"9 ^m.].? l7ju,]8'#c`9#ba.s5 ;?iu,0"1 #aa4dj #aa4he 9#j4ddc"9"9 h7! +>aj3i4 #bjbc c* d],r7`+%a^a #aj`rp1 i=<3 d],r7`+%a $7.v"! ,m$7j3 `]js5o o/i`u [7ibj3 l"<5w ^o%1z ;m;s5,)^1.a #aj`rp1 i=<3 ,m$7j3 d],r7`+%a $7.v ,mcz #j4gea`r" ,m$7 ,o$3z #cb4ff,o$3 .[7$j3 _s["u ;m.]iys/i4 j[7eo"ug .s5z >a #aj`rp1 i=<3 .o;&j3 `+%a^o ;=rao ;m;s5,)^1.7! d<a #a4bi.s5 .[7$j3 _s["u d<7o `v3;[aiys/[c" #e c* jm /l7iycz l15w e3.xiuncz %wj3 ]j>7o ^1`*iy.o <30a #j4egg.s5w .[7$ j+`v$ `v3;[aiys/i4 drct 0,c4v 0,d4cz $a$a ^7! ^g,?j3 `\`v"! +>aj3i4 .o.? ju`o,o5w `]m" 8ccz ,r7$aj`o"! .u0a #j4eia.s5 .[7$j3 _s["u ;m.]iys/i4 0,,ict4 ,[fo1z o1l7,r7jv1 .m7 qhscn' `s5,ra" oeno1" qhscn' ,+do7 eo2 `[5%7`s"r"! tec ..m l+7jcz.on irjr #e.s5 ;?iu"u .o1egj3 egj7! `o.g["u ;[a.]j<:/i4 qhscn' `s5,ra`v oeno1 l+7ncz ^7! eo;o.o eu'jr/[c" qhscn' ,+do7`v `[5%7`s"rcz #j4jfj .[7$,ofocz j+`v$ `v3;[aiys/i4 drct 0,e4cz ^7! +>aj3i4 ;mrsb :^mcz [7ib.$ .oc3 .m ,mobo o/cz o1! jr/cz.o"! `o.g["u d<7! eo;o.o eu'j3 _s["u ;m.]iys/i4 drct 0,f4cz ^7! .n,oj3i4 oh,o5z 8`mrj,`n,s ^x`p3n i7;s5iys/i`u l7l7jr ^u`n/,[bcoi4 l7`[5 #ajj e3 p3 .m7 o1^m"! s":g om'n`n `o^mj1 ,m o/ie* tec `o^mj,o`n/,[bco,$80"a #j4jii .<*"u`[e3f[5 `o^m wj>7o cu47o >a #i4i0p .[7$jr/[5! weoj3i4 `[7.].? l7ju,]z 8cm$ c7o ^1,r7jr/i`u jr,?j1 ,m o/i4 h7n `v3j3 ;y`z *`mi!! ,u`rj<:/i4 #bjai c* d],r7`+%a^a #i4h0pp .[7$,of:/[e:" p1 `+%a^o .o;&! >a #b4f e3 p3 .[7$,ofq _s["u chc/i4 h[ajo ,ui[ao l7ir.?["u cu4z `o.g .m7mr,ui[a #fe0p oj .obi3n,scz ja,[b ;<5:%1o >a #ag4d0pp .[7$j`u" p1 `+%a^o .o;&o >a #c4b e3 p3 .[7$jcz i[7 is fz j+`v$ `v3;[aiys/i4 ,iuj3 ,mj/.7 ,]`:aw ja,[b ;<5:$ .m"u .[7$jcz `]j>7o jvaqiys/i4 ^a #fa4g0pp .[7$j<:/[e:" `+%a^o .o;&z ^a #di e3 p3" p1d]`%3["ucz >a #d4i e3 p3 .[7$j<:/i4"9#b,0 ocz ^7! eo;o.o <307j3 ^ocui=,o.7 ,]`v"! j>7l7,ofq _s["u chc/i4 h[ajo oh,o5" h7j3 egjvv `v3.s5n irj3 .(.m7o $7jviys/[e:" hmd+ eo2 .7o cu4<.ocz i[7 ,oeqw,oaiu j>7l7 -----------------------------#cb iys/i4 ,iuj3 l7ir^7w juw.? hriuncz ^uibj`u" `=`:a.? hriuncz ^u^xj.o <30[":cz `]j>7o .[7$j<:/i4 o"sj3 `\`vcz d],r7ja,[b ;<5:$ ,mj/.702 .m7 .n#d.7" *`m^u`u,s #bjbj-#jh" j3`ma`r^1*`mp3 ^a%3,m"2^am"<58'#bjbd,0" ;8#bjbc c* d],r7`+%a^7! eo;ocz$8 ^1jr7o1"1 #bjbd c* #abp1 ^1jr7;s"1 `ma$d],r7`+%a.qj[7p3 ^1jr7q"1 p3.7 .oaemirjr7 ,o5j3,oa .m,u"1 ,s&h[a^\,o .m7`m ;]`/;)"u #ad .)jv"1 #jb-#cghj-#igjj ju5dno.o"1 0https3_/_/www4nile4or4kr4 q,vr;s"1 8'.m,0fnon,[,n3,no,* #jb-#gfa-#jjca _9 js"